1

AIG: 'Thanks for the bailout. See you in court?'

Logo of insurer American International Group Inc. outside their office in the lower Manhattan area of New York.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Remember the name AIG? That’s the insurance giant that was at the heart of the financial crisis. Remember that it was the single biggest bailout recipient -- getting $182 billion -- and that it recently paid back the government in full?

So imagine this: AIG’s board of directors tomorrow will hear an extraordinary presentation. Former CEO Maurice Greenberg will try to persuade the board to join his lawsuit against the U.S. government, alleging shareholders were shortchanged in the bailout.

“Let me just say, it is Kafkaesque,” says Phil Angelides, who chaired the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission. 

Greenberg, who is still a big AIG shareholder, first sued the government in 2011 for $25 billion. He alleges shareholders were not paid enough for the stake the government took in the company.

And, that brings us to that surreal board meeting, where government officials will also be be making a presentation, asking, in effect, “You sure you want to sue us?”

“I’d pay for first class seats to be in that room,” says Henry Hu, a law professor at the University of Texas and a former SEC regulator.  

He says AIG’s board has an obligation to consider the lawsuit because of shareholder interests, “but they should also consider the costs of this in terms of their relationship with the regulators.” 

Don’t forget, AIG is the company that just started running ads saying -- no joke -- “Thank you America.”

A spokesman for the New York Fed said the allegations have no merit because  bankruptcy was AIG’s only alternative. That would have wiped out shareholders entirely.  

Angelides thinks the board shouldn’t consider this lawsuit for more than a minute. 

“This is a real slap at the taxpayers of the country and a real slap at the government of the United States,” he says. 

AIG issued a written statement today saying it will follow the law and consider the suit. In earlier email to Marketplace, an AIG spokesman declined to comment. Though he did say Thank You.

Carl Tiska's picture
Carl Tiska - Jan 8, 2013

Thanks for a great lead story, although I am not the least bit surprised. I recently listened to Mr Greenberg speak on Robert Shiller's Financial Markets course on Open Yale - http://oyc.yale.edu/economics/econ-252-11/lecture-14
Note that Mr. Greenberg speaks of shareholders twice and clients just once in the hour long lecture - hubris - absolutely, denial is another word that comes to mind. He speaks of the economic destruction that Elliot Spitzer caused but not a mention of the economic destruction AIG caused for taxpayers and citizens. He talks about how he built the culture of AIG over years and then blames AIG's disastrous experience with CDS on the CEO who replaced him cancelling a weekly meeting. I am not exaggerating, listen for yourself. Amazing and disheartening; hopefully the AIG board will demonstrate less hubris.