University of Chicago political science professor Cathy Cohen’s ongoing GenForward survey examines millennial perceptions of major societal and political issues across race and gender, aiming specifically to shed light on underrepresented voices. Recently, the survey tackled millennial views on how best to improve public education.
Marketplace Morning Report host David Brancaccio talked with Cohen about her findings. The following is an edited transcript of their conversation.
David Brancaccio: I used to know a comedian who had this shtick. He discussed some problem, any problem, and then asked, "What's my point? More money for education," he would say is the answer to every single problem. That's, in a sense, what you found when the question is education.
Cathy Cohen: I think that's true. Clearly millennials have seen his routine. When we ask young people any number of questions about the best way to improve public education they always circle back to increasing funding for public education. They want to pay teachers more, they want to invest in neighborhood schools and overall, they want to give more funding to public education.
Brancaccio: And one of the features of your survey is that you do glean data based on the race of the respondent and the gender. What did you find? Was there a difference depending on who is answering?
Cohen: You know, our survey — the Gen Forward survey — is really focused on dis-aggregating our data by race and ethnicity and gender. And in this case, it doesn't seem to matter very much. Overwhelmingly, young people — I don't want to say independent of race and ethnicity but with their races and ethnicity, so across race and ethnicity - support this idea of increasing funding for education on any number of dimensions. So this is a pretty consistent finding that seems to kind of extend across race and ethnicity.
Brancaccio: And how would your respondents use the money if there were more money for education?
Cohen: Well they'd do a number of different things, right? They would increase funding for teachers or pay for teachers, they'd invest again in neighborhood schools. There is a clear sense in the findings that young people believe that the most effective way to impact public education is through really those kind of relationships in the classroom. It would be great, I think they would say, if we had more charter schools or we supported vouchers but if given a priority with a limited amount of money, they want to give it to teachers, they want to support teachers, they want to strengthen teachers unions. They believe in that kind of intimate relationship between the teacher and the student. That's where in fact we should be making the investment according to millennials.
Brancaccio: What about the issue of teachers unions often criticized from the right as protecting bad teaching? What happened when you ask millennials about this?
Cohen: We wanted to focus in on really important issues that have animated the discussion around education. So we wanted to force a choice among respondents to say, "Do you support strengthening teachers unions or do you believe in fact we'd be better off weakening or ending teachers unions?" And what we find is that overwhelmingly, young people, both young people of color and young whites, support strengthening teachers unions really in an upwards of 88 percent to 70 percent.
Brancaccio: What about views of if it's not exactly public school? I'm talking about private schools, but also talking about the charter school movement.
Cohen: It's complicated, I guess I would say, in the sense that young people are looking to improve education so they're supporting any number of strategies. They are supportive of increasing the number of charter schools. They are supportive of providing vouchers using government funds for low-income students so they are supportive of those types of strategies. But I want to go back and say when given a list that says, "Here are a number of options for improving public education: one option is to increase school choice through vouchers, another one is to increase the number of charter schools, another is to invest in public education at the local level," they choose investing in public education at the local level. They choose increasing school funding, investing in neighborhood schools [and] providing teachers with increased pay. Those are their priorities.
“I think the best compliment I can give is not to say how much your programs have taught me (a ton), but how much Marketplace has motivated me to go out and teach myself.” – Michael in Arlington, VABEFORE YOU GO