3

What's happened to the middle class?

The American dream

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Jeremy Hobson: The Federal Reserve kicks off a meeting today in Washington, and we're in for another debate over
which is a bigger concern for the U.S. economy -- inflation, or unemployment.

The Fed is expected to choose unemployment -- and announce it's shifting some of its investments in order to bring down interest rates on things like mortgages and car loans. That's supposed to get the middle class borrowing and spending again.

Well it's the future of the middle class
that concerns Don Peck. He's a writer for the Atlantic, and he's got a big story in the September issue called: "Can the Middle Class Be Saved?" Don Peck joins us now. Good morning.

Don Peck: Good morning.

Hobson: How do you define the middle class, first of all?

Peck: Well I mean, I think that many college graduates today define themselves as middle class and are very worried. They should be, because of the economic weakness we're seeing. But really what I was looking at was what I call the "non-professional middle class" -- people with a high school diploma, but not a college degree. These are the people that are really struggling in the U.S. today.

Hobson: What is the main cause of it?

Peck: You know, even before the recession, this was a group that was under siege because of the technological substitution of labor and because of global offshoring. And what we saw in this recession is the acceleration of both of those trends: companies pulled forward offshoring decisions, restructuring decisions that otherwise would have taken years. And high school graduates have really suffered as a result.

Hobson: I think a lot of people think that in order to succeed in the future economy, you'll have to have a college degree. But you write that that might not actually be the case for everyone.

Peck: I think we should support college education for anyone who wants it and try to widen it. But the fact is that only 30 percent of American adults -- even young adults -- have a college degree, and that number has been increasing extremely slowly. So I don't think that college education can be the entire answer to the woes of the middle class. I think we need to find ways to build pathways into the middle class for people who finish high school but aren't necessarily cut out for college.

Hobson: Do you think that there's some view from the sort of Donna Reed, 1950s, that a family is supposed to be able to have a big house in the suburbs and a car and maybe take a vacation every once in a while, but that in fact, in the future or even now, that's not the middle class anymore -- that's just the rich?

Peck: Well, I think it would be a shame if that were the case. We can quibble about house sizes and the like; I think houses probably got a little too big for a while. But I think an important part of the American idea is a broad middle class -- a prosperous, upwardly mobile middle class. And my worry is that absent, aggressive and really wide-ranging action to rebuild our middle class over time, we could be left with more of a two-tier society, and I think that would be unfortunate and not a country that many Americans would really want to live in.

Hobson: Don Peck of the The Atlantic. His new book is "Pinched: How the Great Recession Has Narrowed Our Futures and What We Can Do About It." Don Peck, thanks so much.

Peck: Thank you, it's my pleasure.

Lorri Wallace's picture
Lorri Wallace - Sep 20, 2011

Global outsourcing isn't just a phenomenon of the recession. Companies have doing it for years. The large technology firm for which I work, outsourced 70% of their IT to India and Argentina. And these are folks with college degrees. The remaining 30% of the jobs here in the US are being consumed by non-Americans. The government makes it far too easy to outsource jobs by allowing companies tax write-offs.

Further, the attack on the middle class, while exacerbated by the recession, has been going on for decades. The middle and lower classes are taxed based on labor while the rich or upper management earn their income mostly in capital markets. e.g. the Buffet statement. Not the mention also the recent statistic that noted that real income has been static for the average male wage-earner since 1972.

Brian Starkey's picture
Brian Starkey - Sep 20, 2011

We (the middle class) have been under attack for decades. That's why I yell at my radio when a republican says O'Bama's plan is class warfare! They have not and will not be in our shoes EVER. The middle class will contiue to feed the greed expressed and put into action by government and wall street. It will never end and folks like us will end up homeless while politicos will debate and debate and debate on how to help us without ever really helping us. We feed the need of greed!

Max Power's picture
Max Power - Sep 20, 2011

"...a family is supposed to be able to have a big house in the suburbs and a car..." It's amusing that this piece bemoans the fact that fewer people are expanding into the lifestyle that is demonized as unsustainable suburban sprawl in other Marketplace stories.