Ask Money

Cut back on tax-sheltered savings

Chris Farrell Jul 8, 2010

Question: I am a public employee in my early 40s and mandated to contribute 5% of my gross salary to a pension plan. I have contributed the max to a Roth IRA ever since they came into existence (and converted my then existing regular-IRA to a Roth & paid the taxes owed on it). I also make small contributions to a deferred comp plan. Question: when “rules of thumb” talk about 15% being enough for a comfortable retirement, does this mean gross salary or take home after taxes? What about the $ I have pulled out for my health plan and optional life insurance payments?

Issue: to free up some cash to pay off a small credit card and build up emergency cash, I’m considering ceasing contributions to my deferred comp plan and take the extra after-tax cash and pay off the credit card, save up some cash, etc. Your thoughts would be most welcome. Thanks, Patrick, St. Paul, MN

Answer: The rule of thumb when it comes to savings is that people should strive for saving between 10% and 20% of gross income. The percentage of your income includes both retirement money and other savings, such as an emergency fund.

Now, rules of thumb are just that: A guideline, a suggestion, rather than a hard and fast rule. A lot more goes into the saving for retirement calculation. For instance, a tenured university professor with a good pension can reasonably set aside less money on a monthly basis compared to a salesman on commission with an income that fluctuates a lot. Other things to consider is what will you end up doing later in life (and it’s usually a variation of what you have done over the years). I know some retired folks that spend relatively little since they enjoy hiking, biking, canoeing and hanging out with the grandchildren while other couples spend a lot more because they can’t wait to travel to another overseas destination.

Still, you can get a rough sense of how you stand by running the numbers at a website such as The website has a lot of good calculators to help you think through savings, debt reduction, and other critical personal finance issues.

Now to your specific question: I would definitely suspend putting extra payments into the deferred compensation plan. I would get rid of the credit card debt and build up savings. You’ll be in much better financial shape if you do this. I’m a big believer in adding to savings outside of tax-sheltered retirement plans.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.