20

Tackling poverty along with reading and arithmetic

Fourth-grader Charles Marsh gets a checkup at Oyler School's health clinic. Nurse practitioner Dilruba Rahman treats students at school and bills their insurance or Medicaid.

- Amy Scott/Marketplace

Principal Craig Hockenberry. The school walls trumpet Oyler's improving academic performance.

- Amy Scott/Marketplace

Darlene Kamine is executive director of Cincinnati's Community Learning Center Institute.

- Amy Scott/Marketplace

Jami Harris escorts children onto the bus after school. A former bank manager, she now coordinates all the nonprofit partners working at Oyler.

- Amy Scott/Marketplace

Rachel Tapp teaches fifth and sixth grade math at Oyler.

- Amy Scott/Marketplace

Senior Matthew Applegate, right, practices an "elevator pitch" with mentor Jim Stillgenbauer. Seniors at Oyler are assigned mentors to motivate them to graduate and go to college.

- Amy Scott/Marketplace

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Kai Ryssdal: Education is the great equalizer. It's historically the path out of poverty in this country. But how do you get poor kids to do well in class if they're not getting enough to eat at home? Or they need glasses? Or their parents can't help them with their homework at night?

What if you took care of a lot of the stuff that's supposed to happen outside school in school?

In the second of two stories on education and poverty, Marketplace's Amy Scott takes us to a school in Cincinnati trying to do exactly that.


Amy Scott: Charles Marsh has a sore throat.

Dilruba Rahman: Go ahead and stick your tongue out. Ah.

Charles Marsh: Ah.

Rahman: Big "ah."

Charles: Aaaah.

Charles is a fourth-grader at Oyler School in Cincinnati's Price Hill. And today, instead of leaving school to see a doctor, he's walked down the hall to the health clinic, where nurse practitioner Dilruba Rahman takes a look.

Rahman: So guess what Charles...

She tells him he has strep.

Charles: I do?

Rahman: Yeah, but it's OK. I called in some antibiotic for you, it's going to be at the Walgreens. And as soon as you go home, start taking it and you can come to school tomorrow...

Most of the kids at Oyler are considered poor. Without this clinic a lot of them would get their basic care in emergency rooms. Instead they come to Rahman for vaccinations, checkups and when they're sick. And she bills Medicaid.

Oyler doesn't just have a health clinic. A dental van provides regular checkups. A vision clinic will open next year.

Craig Hockenberry: We tried to create this vision of a one-stop shop.

Craig Hockenberry is principal at Oyler.

Hockenberry: So if a parent walks through our door right now and has a child that's sick, needs glasses, has a mental health issue, we don't have to send them anywhere else.

The school has three full-time therapists and a psychiatrist who can prescribe medications. Lower Price Hill, where most of the kids live, is one of the toughest neighborhoods in the city.

Hockenberry says children at Oyler are dealing with stresses most of us wouldn't believe.

Hockenberry: Rape, murder, incest, incarceration -- anything that you can imagine that goes along with poverty, and a lot of it went untreated. And over time, we were able to get children into counseling, and we saw our suspensions and a lot of our behaviors go down.

In the late 1990s the Ohio Supreme Court found the conditions of public schools in the state unconstitutionally bad. Leaders in Cincinnati decided to rebuild its schools as community learning centers, schools that would be hubs of their neighborhoods, with an array of social services and after school programs.

Today, the district has one of the largest networks of community schools in the country. Darlene Kamine directs the Community Learning Center Institute. She says when she brought the idea to Lower Price Hill about eight years ago, she was floored by the response.

Darlene Kamine: The room was packed, standing room only and out into the hallway, with people who were quite angry.

At the time, Oyler only went through eighth grade. Parents wanted a high school. The neighborhood is mostly urban Appalachian -- that is people, mostly white, with roots in the Appalachian Mountains.

Kamine says the culture is so insulated parents didn't want to send their children to high schools outside the neighborhood. So after eighth grade, most students dropped out.

Kamine: Children from this neighborhood were in fact not graduating from high school. In the Census data, there was no evidence that anybody in this community had gone to college at the time.

So they decided to rebuild Oyler School as a community learning center that went all the way through 12th grade. Today it has about 750 students. The school serves breakfast, lunch and an afternoon snack. After school programs include nutrition and computer classes and dance. Oyler has college and career counselors, hundreds of volunteer tutors.

Most of this is provided by nonprofits that operate rent-free in the school using their own funding. Every obstacle that poverty presents -- absent parents, asthma, hunger -- the school fights back with some service.

Jami Harris: Fridays are totally the worst day of my week, because I have to decide which of our kids are hungrier.

Coordinating all of these services is an ex-bank manager named Jami Harris. Bracelets jangling, she walks several miles a day, back and forth down the hallways, corralling kids. On Fridays, she sends the neediest students home with food to get them through the weekend.

Harris: We've got some beef stew, we've got red beans and rice, usually cereal, a pudding, a fruit cup.

School leaders say this community approach is making a difference. Students are doing better on state tests. Six years ago, Oyler was considered an "academic emergency" by the state. Now it's making "continuous improvement."

Rachel Tapp: I think the biggest impact is that the kids are here.

Rachel Tapp teaches fifth and sixth grade math. She says when she started at Oyler 10 years ago, attendance was phenomenally low.

Tapp: And now, if they have a need, it's filled within the school and usually outside of the academic time. So they're in their seats and they're learning so much more of the time.

This spring, Oyler will graduate its third class of seniors. One of them is Matthew Applegate. He didn't think he could afford college. But an Oyler mentoring program taught him how to get financial aid.

Matthew Applegate: That's always been a big goal for me, was to go to college. My family has never been real big in college and I want to change that.

Remember just 10 years ago, almost no one from Oyler finished high school. This year, out of 38 seniors, 36 are on track to get their diplomas. All of them have been accepted to college.

In Cincinnati, I'm Amy Scott for Marketplace.

About the author

Amy Scott is Marketplace’s education correspondent covering the K-12 and higher education beats, as well as general business and economic stories.

Pages

mellifluous's picture
mellifluous - May 11, 2012

The free marketeers seem to think that there is an abundance of good-paying jobs with benefits in Cincinnati that people in Price Hill are disdaining to work. They also seem to think that although schools shouldn't provide services to underprivileged kids, that Child Protective Services is some happy and wholesome repository for deserving children that doesn't take any tax money. Such views are so divorced from reality as to be breathtaking in their ignorance. (Libertarians often complain bitterly about not being taken seriously. As soon as they start admitting the failures of market-based economics, including costs that are are transferred to innocent parties without our consent and institutionalized fraud and hypocrisy, they'll gain more credibility.)

While I don't doubt that there are some people who shouldn't procreate -- I'm one of them, I couldn't afford to and luckily, I didn't -- asking what we want to have happen to people who are born into disadvantaged circumstances is a legitimate proposition for society to debate. Shouldn't we be concerned that too much of compulsory education is essentially consumer conditioning and training for prison?

Anti-unionists complain that paying workers living wages with access to good health care at a reasonable cost and pensions prohibitively runs up the cost of doing business. Using tax money to enable states and municipalities to provide services that are unobtainable from lower-wage jobs is also anathema to them. So what's left, especially for those of us who have been rendered extraneous by unemployment that is built into our economic system?

My retired parents live in -- to contrast with Lower Price Hill, named in the story -- what we might call Upper Price Hill and they volunteer to tutor at Oyler once a week. I'm proud of them for altruistically using their own time and effort to help kids in their neighborhood achieve more than they might otherwise and in so doing, incrementally improving the overall conditions of life here in Cincinnati.

blackheartwench's picture
blackheartwench - May 10, 2012

Did you actually read or listen to this story? "Remember just 10 years ago, almost no one from Oyler finished high school. This year, out of 38 seniors, 36 are on track to get their diplomas. All of them have been accepted to college." Wow! They are doing something right.

Just because people are poor, uneducated, or do not have health insurance does not mean that they are drunkards, addicts, horrible people, nor bad parents.

I am sure all of these "parents" (as you call them) would love to have a well paying job with benefits and be able to take the day off to take their children to the doctor. They don't. So let's take their children away. Wait... let's not let them have children at all.

michblas-It gave me chills as well! People like db123 are carrying fire. Thank you.

Austrian School's picture
Austrian School - May 10, 2012

If a child comes to school hungry on a regular basis, wouldn't be better to send CPS (Child Protective Services) to this home rather than couple of sandwitches? These kids deserve better.

bettylo8's picture
bettylo8 - May 10, 2012

This is a tough one isn't it? I certainly have compassion for the children - no doubt about that - but if you take away the parents obligations then it frees up what little resources they have to do less productive things with the money. No? Not realistic? Well, maybe I'm the optimist. In the long run all children would be better off living with a responsible adult. Let's implement policies that encourage parental responsibility - not policies that encourage the opposite. If there is a genuine need then it is difficult - no doubt - but IF the reality is that the parent can purchase one more beer or stay out at the bar a little longer or come home a little drunker (I know it's a stereotype) then how is the child better off?

db123's picture
db123 - May 10, 2012

It is easy for us to sit in our high rise offices and go home to our nice homes in the suburbs and say what "should" be done, and assume that they are all drunks and drug addicts. These students come from families who are the working poor. My mentee lives with her married parents who both work in a factory for minimum wage. She has 3 siblings. They are just above the federal poverty line. They are one hospital co-pay or one car repair away from choosing between that and groceries. Public tranist in Cincinnati is practically non-existent so having a car is a necessity to get to work. Having health services provided in the school allows the students to be treated and stay in school. Taking an un-paid day off work to take a child to the doctor for a sore throat is not an option.

bettylo8's picture
bettylo8 - May 10, 2012

Well, if the reality is what you say then this is all a subsidy for business in the end. We are relieving their factory employers from paying them a livable wage. Remember that food stamps is a subsidy for big agriculture - not poor people. The poor who utilize the food stamps are just the 'courier' to make the transfer appear legitimate and palatable. Why not give the factory a tax break directly or even a tax credit so they can pay higher wages and then the parents can at least maintain some dignity? Plus you get a happy employee. Just think of the effect on the children when they see that their parents can provide for them and they don't need to (as far as they can see) look to the state for their next meal. I'm afraid we are looking at this all wrong my friend.

db123's picture
db123 - May 10, 2012

I am one of the army of mentors who tutors at Oyler once a week. Each Monday, I hurry to my car from my downtown office, drive 15 minutes to Oyler, spend 30 minutes with a 5th grade student listening to her read and helping her think through her answers to the questions on worksheets. There is no wasted time. The one day she was absent, I was given another student to work with. It's only 30 minutes, but between 4 of us (Monday through Thursday), she gets 2 hours of extra reading. She is a student who is on the cusp of passing the Ohio Academic Assessment and it is her mentors' job to help lift her over the top. The test was last week so we will see. At the end of the 30 minutes, we have a few minutes to chat about her life and have exchanged letters. Then I hop in my car, grab lunch and am back at my desk. My company and many others in Cincinnati have embraced this program in order to make a difference in the future of the children and the city. Before this program, I had no connection to Cincinnati Public Schools (I live in Kentucky), but am thoroughly enjoying my time in the library and will miss it when summer comes. Mr. Hockenberry should be named administator of the year. What he has done in this school is amazing. Shout out, also to Ms. Neville, who keeps the A.P. Hampton Tutoring program running like a well "oyled" machine.

bettylo8's picture
bettylo8 - May 10, 2012

I don't know, it seems to me like if you stayed open on the weekend you would be running an orphanage. Why not call it what it is?

Austrian School's picture
Austrian School - May 10, 2012

Good point. I guess if they called it an orphanage then the "parents" would have to give up custody. This way they can have all of us pay public employees to take care of their kids.

michblas's picture
michblas - May 10, 2012

This story struck me how it really does take a village to raise a child. That a school district would see the importance of providing all these services to poor students is amazing. Why can't more school districts create programs like this? The story gave me the chills that people care so much. God Bless these educators and community workers

Pages