15

Take My Daughter: Confessions of a Chinese baby trafficker

The international adoption scandal was widely reported across China.

- Marketplace

Duan Yueneng and his mother live in a city in Hunan province called Hengyang in China.

- Cecilia Chen / Marketplace

Convicted baby trafficker Duan Yueneng.

- Cecilia Chen / Marketplace

Duan Yueneng's mother

- Cecilia Chen / Marketplace

Petition documents from Duan Yuneng

- Cecilia Chen / Marketplace

A Proof of Abandonment document

- Marketplace

Duan Yueneng sits together with his mother while talking about baby selling as a family business

- Cecilia Chen / Marketplace

A sample of orphanage logs

- Marketplace

A receipt sample

- Marketplace

Duan's family brought the baby from Wuchuan, Guangdong province, 621 miles away from Changning, Hunan province.

- google.com

Convicted baby trafficker Duan Yueneng.

A receipt sample

Duan Yueneng's mother


"Do you want to take my daughter?"

Convicted baby trafficker Duan Yueneng uttered those words moments after I stepped into his apartment to interview him. As far as I could tell (and my assistant Cecilia Chen next to me), Mr. Duan was not kidding. His daughter, by the way, stood about five feet away. This man has been busted for selling Chinese baby girls, and he's trying to offload his own child. I declined.

"My second baby was a girl," Duan said. "Because the one-child policy was very strict then, I wanted to get rid of her, so that I still have a chance to have a baby boy. After all, you need to have a boy.

"My mother didn't want to abandon her, nor did my mother-in-law. I tried a couple times putting my second daughter on the street but nobody wanted her. I finally took her back. Now she's 15 as you see."

Illegal adoptions a 'demand-driven market'

Duan kept a straight face throughout the interview. He described the international adoption economy as a demand-driven market. Parents from America and elsewhere wanted to adopt Chinese infants. These parents paid $3,000 to the child's orphanage, under Chinese rules. Naturally, orphanages supplied babies, in some cases buying babies from Duan, the supplier.

His mother was part of the action, too. She was transporting infants from Zhanjiang, Guangdong -- where they bought babies from another supplier -- to Changning, Hunan. A 600-mile trip.

"We put six babies in three big powdered milk cardboard boxes," Duan's mother told us during the interview. "We put two babies in each box. My daughter went with me. We boarded the train at Zhanjiang station. In the middle of the trip, one box fell. Then, I started feeding them, one after another. Each of us was holding one baby and we had other four babies in two boxes."

Exposing the paper trail

Then came the documents from Duan's official court file. Orphanage receipts revealed when babies changed hands and for how much. Bank transfers accompanied the receipts, often the money went to an account in the name of Duan's aunt. Orphanage logs showed when infants arrived, and who brought them. Often the deliverer -- the official baby finder -- was one of Duan's sisters. Or his mother. In other words, these babies were not found in the neighborhood by a good Samaritan, as the typical narrative would put it. They were sold to the orphanage.

The papers we saw -- just a portion of Duan's court file -- showed at least one baby delivered by the traffickers was adopted by an American couple. We saw their names, their adoption papers, official copies of their passports, but chose not to name them in the story. What if they don't want to know?

Breaking through China's lack of transparency

When I moved to China in early 2007, a fellow foreign journalist described China this way:

"It's like looking through three panes of glass. You can't get very close." Indeed, it can be maddeningly difficult to get near the real action, the real players.

In this case, many sources spoke to us on condition of anonymity. The Chinese government refused to talk for the record, as did every orphanage director we tried. We called the lead adoption ministry in China several times before someone even confirmed basic facts about Chinese adoption policy. We showed up at one Hunan orphanage, and after the director sat us down, offered us tea and took our business cards, he declared himself "too busy" for an interview.

Even basic adoption and orphanage numbers are scarce: one Chinese scholar in the field told us this is such a sensitive topic even he can't get access to the numbers.

Research shows the problem might not be getting much better. Dutch social worker Ina Hut says we may never know even if it does. Hut used to direct the largest adoption agency in Holland. When the Hunan scandal broke, Hut told me she sought an independent investigation in China, to see if any trafficked babies ended up going to Holland. She says Chinese officials denied her, as did her home government. When Hut pushed the issue, she says Dutch officials warned her it would endanger relations with China. And, she says, Dutch officials vowed to revoke her agency's adoption license if she persisted. Hut quit last year in protest.

For more on this story, listen to my radio report and read more reactions from American families with adopted Chinese babies.

Pages

jcdcameron's picture
jcdcameron - May 6, 2013

Each on of us is fighting for the difficulties we faced in our lives but for children's case they cannot fight for their own because they are not well stable in terms of thinking and other strategies to coup up with life's difficulty that why parents are there to support us all the way until children can stand on their own but how come some parents are the cause of the children's agony. Trafficking should be stop and parents who engaged their children into this should be punished.
<a href="http://www.aaflc.org">missing children</a>

Amanda de Lange's picture
Amanda de Lange - May 16, 2010

Here is another side to this which needs to be considered: If they are paying for the babies, I would think that they would treat their "investment" better. It could save the child's life but in my experience the foundlings have very little value and can be expendable. If each life was valued, then I am sure just by doing the math, that there will be enough children for domestic and international adoptions.

Kris Smith's picture
Kris Smith - May 13, 2010

You may not display email addresses, but city and state are displayed. So I tried to locate less common last names with smaller cities and states and came up with addresses and phone numbers. You might want to rethink supplying city and state for security sake. I'm not being crass, just offering a warning.

Ruby Hung's picture
Ruby Hung - May 11, 2010

I do not support child trafficking but on the brighter side; on the assumption the children were not "kidnapped" from their parents, the one child policy leaves many baby girls unwanted and in some cases drowned, put in orphanages ect... Adoption on the other hand, gives them a life that they would not otherwise have had.

Different forms of child trafficking exist within China where baby girls are sent to live with her appointed spouse's family in exchange for a roof over their head and basic daily needs b/c her family is too poor to support her.

There's more than one side to a story of course, and anything could be twisted for ill personal gains; like child trafficking, however, adoption of baby girls from China should not be taken off the list just because things like this happens.

J N's picture
J N - May 9, 2010

As an adoptive mother I would definintely want to know if my child was a victim of child trafficking or an illegal adoption and I would venture to guess that most adoptive parents would also want to know. Not to mention the adopted children who are victims have a right to know.
The article doesn't mention the children that are taken away from their birth parents by coercion and then sold to orphanages. http://articles.latimes.com/2009/sep/20/world/fg-china-adopt20

Who are we to say that our adopted children are better off here in America than with their birth families in China. Trust me...you will change that egocentrical thinking the first time you see your child in deep emotional pain over their loss/separation or if you ever witness a grieving birthparent who had their child stolen/kidnapped.

I have a lot of respect for the Dutch Social Worker, Ina Hunt for "not turning a blind eye" to the possiblity that some children placed from China could be victims of child trafficking. She too deserves an "Angel in Adoption" award.

CeeCee D's picture
CeeCee D - May 7, 2010

To Elizabeth Ellis from Vernon, Vermont:

There has been news coverage of abducted Chinese children, including news of protests by parents who feel Chinese law enforcement is not doing enough. See the following:

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/05/world/asia/05kidnap.html

http://www.rnw.nl/international-justice/article/parents-abducted-childre...

I am not aware that there has been a demonstrated connection between the child abductions in China and children adopted internationally. The stories I've read say the child abductions are being fueled by domestic demand.

Elizabeth Ellis's picture
Elizabeth Ellis - May 7, 2010

Are there parents in China claiming that their children were kidnapped? I would think that this should be looked into and reported on in order to fully investigate this issue. There are still too many questions.

MidiAna Bilik-Franklin's picture
MidiAna Bilik-F... - May 6, 2010

Thanks for this story...I think the Hague created more problems with the China adoption program because it forced the smaller agencies out of placing children, so now there are only big agencies with big relationships.I think that another interesting story would be about China special needs adoptions, where the special needs were a result of trafficing. How many babies from the trafficers ended up with serious problems as a result of being carted around in boxes, duffle bags, etc? How many of the kids on the street in China begging with visible disabilities are actually in the custody of the orphanages? I think the underworld is alot more involved with international adoption than most people feel comfortable thinking about.

Katy Bridges's picture
Katy Bridges - May 6, 2010

Why in all this coverage of the darker side of adoptions in China is there no mention of the Hague Convention that was adopted in 2007? This convention made rules much more strict for international adoption. Since 2007, the wait to adopt from China has increased dramatically so that conditions for insuring that children have been legitimately released for adoption can be met. The system may not be perfect, but the Chinese government is taking positive action.

On a related note, many people who want to adopt end up being victims before they travel to their children. How about doing a story on agencies in the US and Canada that are stringing along their clients who signed up years ago to adopt from China, and after years of waiting come up with thousands of dollars in last minute fees?

Liz Raleigh's picture
Liz Raleigh - May 6, 2010

"What if they don't want to know?" Although this information can be difficult to learn, I would argue that this is a vital part of the child's story and she has a right to this information, even if it is difficult for the parents and child. As an adult Korean adoptee, I would want to know this information. It is part of her story and she deserves to have access to this information.

Pages