82

The fate of comics after newspapers

From the comic strip "Frazz" by Jef Mallett

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

TEXT OF STORY

Bill Radke: One reason newspapers are in trouble is that you can so happily get your news other places. It's fun to scan the Web for stories. It's easy to, you know, check your stocks on your phone. But there's one part of newspapers that seems to go best with a cup of coffee and some crinkly newsprint, and that is the comics section. Reporter John Rabe wanted to know: What happens to comics if newspapers die?


John Rabe: Jef Mallet draws Frazz -- a sweet, smart comic strip about an elementary school janitor -- out of his home in Lansing, Mich.

Jef Mallett: You dream right from the start that it could be a living. I was able to feel confident enough to go strictly full-time with Frazz after about a year of syndication.

Mallett grew up reading standbys like Peanuts, and now he's making his living drawing a strip that runs in 150 U.S. newspapers. But these days the Detroit News, which runs Frazz, only delivers three days a week, and other papers are shutting down or going online only.

Mallett: Sometimes I worry that they're just so ingrained and associated with ink on newsprint that they're just not going to fit quite as well into wherever newspapers go next.

All comics are already online, but nobody's found a way yet to get the web to pay enough so that drawing a strip can stay a full-time job.

Cartoonists are worried. At their annual convention last month, they held a seminar on "The Future of Newspapers and Comics," where Jim Borgman, who draws the strip Zits, heard from a lot of frazzled young artists.

Jim Borgman: Yeah, you may have a syndicated strip. You certainly need to keep a Web site up. You're probably blogging. Some of these guys have like stand-up acts. They're in bands that. you know, somehow cross pollinate with their strip. One guy looked up at me today and said, "You need a staff to do this."

Cartoonist Darrin Bell has chronicled the death of newspapers in his strip, Candorville, and he actually has a tip jar on his Web site. He says the money coming in from the Web -- not just in tips -- is only a quarter of his income as a cartoonist. But he's not worried about comics.

Darrin Bell: Comics have been around basically since the first caveman found the first cave wall.

One thing we're fairly sure cave men didn't draw on cave walls is crossword puzzles. They debuted in newspapers in 1913.

Will Shortz is NPR's Puzzlemaster and editor of the New York Times crossword. He says puzzles will survive in books and online even if newspapers go away, and the economic impact on puzzle makers will be minimal.

Will Shortz: Honestly, most people are making puzzles cause they love it -- they just love the process - and they're anxious to see their names in print. They're not doing it for the money.

Shortz pays his freelancers 200-bucks for a daily puzzle and a thousand for a Sunday puzzle, but since he publishes the work of more than a hundred puzzle makers a year, nobody's making a real living at this except him.

In Los Angeles, I'm John Rabe for Marketplace.

Pages

Amuh Lumas's picture
Amuh Lumas - Jun 7, 2009

To risk beating a dead horse here, "All comics are already online, but nobody's found a way yet to get the web to pay enough so that drawing a strip can stay a full-time job" is such a ridiculous statement as to clearly illustrate the author's complete and utter failing in publishing this article.

<a href="http://lmgtfy.com/?q=full+time+online+comics">Let me google that for you...</a>

Jogn Smythe's picture
Jogn Smythe - Jun 7, 2009

THIS is why newspapers are dying. I am blown away by the fact that you not only chose to write about something you obviously have no clue whatsoever about, but that you also decided not to even attempt to research it. I feel like you literally picked a topic at random, guessed what the answer would be and decided to publish it.

Have you not heard of Fred Gallagher, Randall Munroe, Scott Kurtz, and of course Jerry Holkins and Mike Krahulik, the two of which have made not only more than you will ever, ever make, but also have started a charity and the one of the largest gaming conventions in the world. You are a despicable person and a shitty, shitty, journalist. Shitty.

Christina Tom's picture
Christina Tom - Jun 7, 2009

What a jaw-droppingly poorly researched piece. I would have at least expected a mention of one of the dozens of successful online comics mentioned above by other commenters--maybe even a sound bite from Scott McCloud, author of "Reinventing Comics"--as a counterpoint to the artists who are complaining about not making money online.

And to be perfectly frank, I find most of the Sunday funnies subset of comics to be rather weak unlikely to survive were it not for having the built-in audience of the newspaper. Go forth, Mr. Rabe, and discover the rich world of comics online. Maybe it'll convince you to have your morning cup of coffee in front of the computer like so many of us already do.

Tarol Hunt's picture
Tarol Hunt - Jun 7, 2009

"All comics are already online, but nobody's found a way yet to get the web to pay enough so that drawing a strip can stay a full-time job."

There is an army of online comics that are currently full time, paying jobs for the authors. I myself, have an online comic called Goblins, which is my full time job, supporting myself and my family. I'm simply amazed that a reporter can make a statement like this without even a cursory glance at the internet.

Eric Leslie's picture
Eric Leslie - Jun 7, 2009

"John Rabe wanted to know: What happens to comics if newspapers die?"

John, I've been reading pretty much all my comics online for more than 10 years. And I don't mean hosted versions of printed funnies (though I read those too), I mean online-only comics that have been making their authors money on the web for a decade.

To say you missed the boat here is an enormous understatement. Newspapers could all cease to exist tomorrow and hundreds of thousands of comic fans wouldn't even notice.

Eric Leslie's picture
Eric Leslie - Jun 7, 2009

"John Rabe wanted to know: What happens to comics if newspapers die?"

John, I've been reading pretty much all my comics online for more than 10 years. And I don't mean hosted versions of printed funnies (though I read those too), I mean online-only comics that have been making their authors money on the web for a decade.

To say you missed the boat here is an enormous understatement. Newspapers could all cease to exist tomorrow and hundreds of thousands of comic fans wouldn't even notice.

Steve B's picture
Steve B - Jun 7, 2009

The guys from Penny Arcade and and Tim from CAD do online comics full time. That's what they do. Also Questionable Content creator Jeph J. does his comic five days a week. Check your facts. Webcomics are much more popular and can be a source of actual income.

Kevin Online's picture
Kevin Online - Jun 7, 2009

So I take it you haven't heard of" PVPOnline.com Penny-arcade.com myextralife.com www.dieselsweeties.com www.cad-comic.com learn the facts before you report.

Tristina Wright's picture
Tristina Wright - Jun 7, 2009

So a few comic artists QQ'ed to your paper because they haven't broken into online comics or been successful at it and you turn around and apply a blanket statement to the whole industry? Shame...

I won't repeat the lists of successful webcomics here, but properly researching any story is the first rule of good journalism.

Nick Newman's picture
Nick Newman - Jun 7, 2009

Penny Arcade is doing just fine. It's definitely possible to be a successful webcomic artist.

Pages