Is E-Verify too demanding on business?

An E-Verify poster


KAI RYSSDAL: There will be some changes to labor rules on the heels of Labor Day. Starting Tuesday, federal contractors are going to have to check a job applicant's legal status before letting them begin work. The requirement to use a free online database known as E-Verify is part of an effort to keep undocumented workers off the government payroll.

Marketplace's Jeff Tyler explains.

Jeff Tyler: E-Verify checks a person's identity and citizenship against government databases. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce calls the system a burden for employers. But at least one corporation disagrees.

Charles Brimmer: It's not a very time-consuming program.

Charles Brimmer is with the employment company, Manpower. On any given day, the firm employs about 400,000 people worldwide. Those in the U.S. are all checked using E-Verify.

Brimmer: It takes three to five seconds to get a result right back in the system about their eligibility to work in the United States.

And if Brimmer has problems:

Brimmer: The help desk for the government is great. I've called a variety of times and someone is on the phone within five or 10 seconds. I barely have to wait.

E-Verify can pose challenges for small businesses. Kim Carmichael is with Watson & Cochran, a cabinetmaker in Texas. She had started taking an online tutorial on how to use E-Verify.

Kim Carmichael: There's all this information that you have to read. And you have to take courses and take tests and pass the tests. I spent about a day and a half and I wasn't even half-way finished. So I just quit in the middle of the process and decided that we weren't going to do it.

Carmichael could give up, because her company isn't a government contractor. But that exemption may not last. Congress is considering legislation that would require all employers to use E-Verify.

I'm Jeff Tyler for Marketplace.

About the author

Jeff Tyler is a reporter for Marketplace’s Los Angeles bureau, where he reports on issues related to immigration and Latin America.
Log in to post1 Comment

I'm aghast at the Texas cabinetmaker who gave up on learning the E-verify system. What if I said to her child, "It's ok to give up on learning how to read--reading is hard." As an elementary school teacher, I would be FIRED. Education takes patience and perseverance, regardless of one's age.

With Generous Support From...