2

Undocumented workers pay special fees

Little Village on Chicago's west side in the early morning hours of Jan. 18, 2013. Workers who were told they have work by Rigo walk through an alley to a yellow school bus.

Tens of thousands of undocumented immigrants work in the shadows every day. Because of their legal status, they are vulnerable to exploitation by unscrupulous employers and other shady operators. Undocumented immigrants in Chicago get nickeled and dimed in a way that doesn’t happen to U.S. citizens. Here are some of things they get charged for.

Elizabeth Bellido doesn’t have a social security number. To get a job at a temp agency, she has to use an underground labor broker.

“Either him or his son would fill-out the application for you. They will charge you a $5 fee,” says Bellido.

That’s illegal. But what could she do? Bellido needed the job.

The labor broker also charges $8 a day for a roundtrip ride to the suburbs, where warehouse workers make just over $8 an hour. Bellido says workers who arranged other transportation risked retaliation.

“If you wanted to take your own car, it was kind of like you were taking your own risk of getting laid off,” says Bellido.

At the end of the week, the company didn’t pay Bellido directly.

“You wouldn’t get your check at the factory,” says Bellido. “You actually have to go pick it up at a currency exchange. And so you wouldn’t have the option to do direct deposit, or you bringing your own checks to your bank.”


LISTEN: The Backstory behind 'Taken for a Ride'
ProPublica's Michael Grabell and Marketplace reporter Jeff Tyler answer questions about their joint investigation in this special Marketplace podcast. Listen now


Even immigrants with their own bank accounts are obligated to use a check-cashing service, which charges them one to two percent of their paycheck.

And if the check comes to, say, $200.70, a middle-aged worker named Estela says one check casher often pockets that change.

“He doesn’t give the change because he says he doesn’t have any pennies,” says Estela.

It’s illegal to force workers in Illinois to cash a check at a specific check-casher. And of course it’s illegal to steal a workers’ pennies. But many workers get cheated out of much more money.

“I haven’t been paid for 40 hours,” says a middle-aged woman named Delfina. So she’s out about $350.

And on top of the extra fees paid by the undocumented, people like Isidro Bahena also get hit with the normal deductions.

“From my check, they take $25 for Medicare. And $15 for Social Security,” says Bahena.

He doesn’t ever expect to collect on those benefits. So they become just another fee for working while undocumented.


Read the investigative report from ProPublica's Michael Grabell, and explore more features and background from his reporting on ProPublica.org. Plus, read more from this investigation.

About the author

Jeff Tyler is a reporter for Marketplace’s Los Angeles bureau, where he reports on issues related to immigration and Latin America.
Log in to post2 Comments

You don't have to look to illegal immigrants to see unfair working practices. My "American" brother worked for one of these temp agencies b/c he couldn't find a job when he graduated HS. He wasn't always paid what he was owed, now he works for a shipping company and is constantly having to ask what happened to the pay for all of the hours he works, since his manager often fills in the paper work improperly...Many of his fellow American citizens quit and are unemployed b/c they don't want to put up with the "BS" of low-wage, part-time work...

Jeff you and your liberal ideals have become unglued. UNDOCUMENTED = ILLIGAL. I feel it is wrong for these temp agencies to hire these people in the first place ... how many Americans are unemployed or stopped looking for work? This crap is not fair to Americans and LAW ABIDING IMMIGRANTS!

With Generous Support From...