Marketplace has a new podcast for kids, "Million Bazillion!" EPISODE OUT NOW

China’s competitive coffee shop scene keeps owners on their toes

Jennifer Pak Jun 21, 2021
Heard on:
HTML EMBED:
COPY
Keiichi Nakayama said his coffee shop, Rumors, was the first in Shanghai to specialize in hand-poured coffee more than a decade ago. Charles Zhang/Marketplace

China’s competitive coffee shop scene keeps owners on their toes

Jennifer Pak Jun 21, 2021
Heard on:
Keiichi Nakayama said his coffee shop, Rumors, was the first in Shanghai to specialize in hand-poured coffee more than a decade ago. Charles Zhang/Marketplace
HTML EMBED:
COPY

On Hunan Road in Shanghai’s French Concession, jazz music drifts from a shop with sleek wooden panels and leather seats. The place could easily be mistaken for a bar. Instead, the storefront is a high-end coffee shop called Rumors Coffee.

“When we first opened shop 11 years ago, we were the only ones to specialize in hand-poured coffee,” Rumors co-owner Keiichi Nakayama from Japan said. “We gradually started seeing other shops price their coffee the same as ours.”

Other coffee shops want to copy more than just their price, according to his wife, Liu Yan, who also co-runs the place.

“Some business owners brought their own designers in and started to measure the bar counter secretly. Our menus have been stolen,” she said. “Customers told us that there’s a coffee training school that was using our name.”

Coffee shops are a cutthroat business. It got worse during the COVID-19 pandemic.

According to a study by China’s Tsinghua University that included more than 50,000 companies, nearly 19% of small and micro-sized businesses shut down last year compared to 6.6% in 2019.

Juzi started out as a barista and said the pandemic allowed her to realize her dream to open her own coffee shop. Many others had the same idea in Shanghai  (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Juzi started out as a barista and said the pandemic allowed her to realize her dream to open her own coffee shop. Many others had the same idea in Shanghai. (Photo by Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

The pandemic lockdown can provide opportunities for some, like Juzi, who worked her way up from a barista to an operations manager at one of China’s coffee chains. She quit her job during the pandemic and opened her own coffee shop in June 2020, when Shanghai was fully reopening from a lockdown and she found an affordable rental space.

Rumors Coffee in Shanghai is among the first wave of boutique coffee shops in the Chinese financial capital (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Rumors Coffee in Shanghai is among the first wave of boutique coffee shops in the Chinese financial capital (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Co-owner of Rumors Coffee Liu Yan said their prices, decor and even name have been used as a model by competitors even before the pandemic hit (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Liu Yan, co-owner of Rumors Coffee, said their prices, decor and even name have been used as a model by competitors even before the pandemic hit. (Photo by Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

Pandemic competition

“After I opened my coffee shop, I found that within six months, a few more opened nearby. Coffee shops pop up in Shanghai so fast!” the 27-year-old said.

There are seven to eight coffee shops within a 1-mile radius of her own.

“The life cycle of a coffee shop [in Shanghai] is usually two to three years. We’ve been open for about a year, and this street is already full of coffee shops. I am under big pressure,” Juzi said.

There are at least half a dozen other coffee shops within a one mile radius of Shanghai's Nameless Coffee (left), including one to its right (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
There are at least half a dozen other coffee shops within a 1-mile radius of Shanghai’s Nameless Coffee, left, including one to its right (Photo by Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

She said she does not want to compete on prices since her Americanos, cappuccinos and lattes are already sold below Starbucks prices, which is used as the industry standard in China.

“Some new shops are offering an Americano for 9 yuan [$1.40] … half price if you bring your own cup. That is frightening,” she said. “At that price, I cannot guarantee the quality of the coffee.”

How Starbucks won over China

Starbucks is credited with bringing coffee culture to a nation of tea drinkers. Its first shop opened in Beijing in 1999, and it was a premium experience. A cup of Starbucks cappuccino at the time was 19 yuan, which was equivalent to $2.30, according to Chinese state-run news agency Xinhua. That was beyond the reach of many Chinese consumers "when the same amount could bring back 10 kg [22 pounds] of rice," the news report added. Starbucks founder Howard Schultz told Chinese state broadcaster CGTN that the company did not make a profit for a number of years because it had to educate consumers and cultivate loyalty. As China's middle class grew, Starbucks also expanded. Starbucks currently has 5,000 stores spread across 200 mainland Chinese cities.
With the borders shut during the pandemic, many Chinese customers are spending more domestically, to the benefit of high end coffee shops like Rumors (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
With the borders shut during the pandemic, many Chinese customers are spending more domestically, to the benefit of high-end coffee shops like Rumors (Photo by Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

Surviving 2021

Instead, Juzi says, she stays in the game by researching and promoting new types of coffee every season. She has premium products like ice-dripped coffee, which take six to eight hours to produce one cup and requires advanced orders. Juzi also keeps her staff small and splits her rent with another business.

“We make coffee in the front. They sell paintings and do framing in the back,” Juzi said.

A framing shop in Shanghai leased out the front half of its store to Nameless Coffee during the pandemic to share the burden of rent (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
A framing shop in Shanghai leased out the front half of its store to Nameless Coffee during the pandemic to share the burden of rent (Photo by Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

Rent is the biggest headache for business owners in pricey Shanghai.

During the pandemic, China’s central government announced rent reduction for businesses, but that only applied to those who lease premises from state-owned enterprises.

Nameless Coffee barista Liu Yi seen with ice-drip coffee machines, which take six to eight hours to produce one cup (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Nameless Coffee barista Liu Yi seen with ice-drip coffee machines, which take six to eight hours to produce one cup. (Photo by Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

“To cope with high rent, most coffee shops sell liquor at night or other products,” Rumors Coffee co-owner Liu said. She and her husband have resisted doing so. Their focus is on maintaining quality and variety.

Rumors Coffee roasts its own beans and has 40 types on hand. One cup of hand-dripped coffee costs anywhere from 65 yuan ($10) to 140 yuan ($22).

“A lot of people cannot go abroad because of the pandemic, so people are spending their money here [in Shanghai]. If you serve coffee that pleases people, word will get out and we get repeat business,” Rumors Coffee co-owner Nakayama said. “During the pandemic, the number of customers we’re getting is increasing.”

Keiichi Nakayama roasts his own coffee and keeps 40 varieties on hand at Rumors Coffee for customers to choose (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Keiichi Nakayama roasts his own coffee and keeps 40 varieties on hand at Rumors Coffee. (Photo by Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

He and his wife feel China’s coffee culture is still in its infancy, despite a high concentration of coffee shops in Shanghai.

Coffee market

There are nearly 7,000 coffee shops in Shanghai, and just over half of them are boutique stores like Rumors Coffee and Nameless Coffee, according to a study by a business platform under Yicai. However, outside of the financial capital, coffee shops are not that popular.

“I never drank coffee before working at a coffee shop in Shanghai [at the age of 20],” Liu Yi, the barista at Nameless Coffee, said. “I come from a small Chinese city without a coffee culture.”

Yet, his coffee-making skills have left a deep impression on customers like Xiong Luying, who is a visitor from Wuhan city.

Xiong Luying said the coffee culture is not as developed in Wuhan city, where she works, so she seeks out boutique coffee shops every time she visits Shanghai (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Xiong Luying said the coffee culture is not as developed in Wuhan city, where she works, so she seeks out boutique coffee shops every time she visits Shanghai. (Photo by Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

She had been to Nameless Coffee once before.

“That day I chose a particular bean and … since it was a hot day, I requested an ice coffee,” Xiong said. “The barista said he tried making it twice, but it did not reflect the bean’s best taste. He suggested I change to a hot coffee.”

Suddenly, barista Liu looked up from behind the coffee counter.

“Oh, that was you!” he said, and they struck up a conversation.

In a city of 24 million, the personal touch also makes for repeat customers.

Additional research by Charles Zhang.

We’re here to help you navigate this changed world and economy.

Our mission at Marketplace is to raise the economic intelligence of the country. It’s a tough task, but it’s never been more important.

In the past year, we’ve seen record unemployment, stimulus bills, and reddit users influencing the stock market. Marketplace helps you understand it all, will fact-based, approachable, and unbiased reporting.

Generous support from listeners and readers is what powers our nonprofit news—and your donation today will help provide this essential service. For just $5/month, you can sustain independent journalism that keeps you and thousands of others informed.