A 20-year-old digital copyright law is still being fought about (and copied) today
Share Now on:
You know those music videos you love on YouTube and the memes you love to laugh at? Well, proposed digital copyright laws in Europe and other countries kind of want to make those a little less common. It’s a 20-year-old copyright law here in the U.S. called the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, or DMCA that’s behind the proposed changes.
Cory Doctorow is a writer and activist with the Electronic Frontier Foundation. He calls the DMCA a “big gnarly hairball of a law.”
He and the EFF have been talking about and litigating over the unintended consequences of the DMCA for almost 20 years now. The law was written at a time when it was newly possible to rip CDs and DVDs and put them online. And this big copyright law, the DMCA, was designed to protect companies and artists from having their work stolen and disseminated all over the internet.
But almost from the beginning, critics said the scope of the law was too broad. Doctorow points in particular to one section that covers the circumvention of tools that are designed to protect copyright.
“The idea here was that if you like made a DVD player and you wanted to control whether DVDs bought in another country could play on it, you could make a little like code [to] check to see whether the DVD was bought in the same place as the DVD player,” Doctorow said. “And if not you could refuse to play it.”
The DMCA made it illegal to tamper with things like that little code. It basically made it illegal to break any copyright locks in any product. And that is why you weren’t allowed to open up your smartphone or your tractor to fix it, which we talked about earlier this week.
“And so here we are 20 years later and this tactic is now being used to lock third party ink out of inkjet printers,” Doctorow said. “It’s in voting machines and it’s being used to punish security researchers who audit voting machines because they say if you reveal the defects in the voting machines it might help someone bypass these copyright locks.”
There is a provision in the law for a review, every three years, to consider exemptions. One of those reviews just happened. It gives you more rights to fix your smartphone and your tractor. And back in 2015, the Library of Congress did grant a limited exemption to protect researchers who were trying to find out if voting machines or other electronic systems had security flaws, as long as they were acting in good faith.
But there was a large catch. The researchers can break through digital rights management, DRM, to find out if, for example, a voting machine has a security problem. But if they describe the tools they used to find the flaws, they could get a fine or even go to jail, which means nobody else can verify the research.
“The DMCA should have been phrased in the most common sense way imaginable,” Doctorow said. “Which is to say, if you break DRM to infringe copyright you’re breaking the rules and if you’re breaking DRM and you’re not infringing copyright, you’re allowed to do it.
Refining the DMCA has been a long process, and it’s not just researchers and academics. In 2016, major music industry organizations said another provision of the copyright law was making it too easy for sites like YouTube to keep hosting copyrighted music. And they wanted reforms, too. Kind of ironic since the music industry pushed hard for the original law.
And now for the other tech news we’re following:
- Related to copyright issues: Google is, of course, a huge target of copyright owners. And yes, it has let a lot slip through the cracks over the years. But it put out a report yesterday detailing its 2018 efforts to fight piracy. Google said it’s invested $100 million in tools to spot infringing content. The tools actually scan uploads against a database of copyrighted material,. That’s something the proposed EU copyright law wants everyone to do, in fact, so if someone uploads copyrighted content, the original copyright owner gets ad revenue from it. Imagine that! Google said it’s already paid $3 billion to copyright owners that way. And another $1.8 billion to the music industry in the form of ad revenue. In its report, Google also said that if you give people a way to pay for legitimate content, they are far less likely to steal it. Take note, TV-on-demand people.
- If you are totally bored with smartphone designs (and you probably are because the biggest innovation in the last five years has basically been the notch), then get to the internet and watch a video of Samsung’s foldable smartphone, which it was showing off yesterday at a developer conference. The new Samsung folds out to become a 7-inch tablet and then closes up and there’s a phone screen on the front. Google said the Android operating system will support these crazy doohickeys. Lenovo, Xiaomi, and LG are also working on them.
If you’re a member of your local public radio station, we thank you — because your support helps those stations keep programs like Marketplace on the air. But for Marketplace to continue to grow, we need additional investment from those who care most about what we do: superfans like you.
Your donation — as little as $5 — helps us create more content that matters to you and your community, and to reach more people where they are – whether that’s radio, podcasts or online.
When you contribute directly to Marketplace, you become a partner in that mission: someone who understands that when we all get smarter, everybody wins.