What goes into the decision to create a spinoff?
This has been a big week for the spinoff. General Electric said it’s going to spin several of its divisions, those involved in energy efficiency, renewable generation and storage, into a new company called Current. Yahoo announced it’s going ahead with the spinoff of its stake in Chinese company Alibaba. Canada’s Brookfield Asset Management said it would spin off almost all of its business services and industrial operations assets. Sony said it’s going to spin off its semiconductor business, and Sunday saw the debut of “Teresa Checks In,” the spinoff from the “Real Housewives of New Jersey” that will follow the family of Teresa Giudice while she’s in jail.
OK, the last isn’t a corporate spinoff, I know, but it does illustrate one of the reasons that companies decide to spin off parts of their operations. By the way, if you prefer to consume your explainers in video form, check out the short clip above.
Bravo created the “Teresa Checks In” spinoff for one reason only: to make money. The company figured that Teresa is such a colorful character (OMG, she’s in JAIL!) that people will spend an hour of their precious time watching her family’s tribulations on a stand-alone show. Teresa is kind of like a division in a corporation: The company believes the division will do better, and make more money, as a stand-alone brand and entity. So it spins the division off. Making sure, of course, to hold a nice, fat stake in the new company so it can share in the profits.
Comparing Teresa with a corporate spinoff only goes so far, of course. For one thing, she’s only getting three shows, so Bravo is keeping its exposure to a minimum. For another, it’s not clear whether she’s not actually being spun off altogether — she may or may not return to the show once she’s out of jail. In a corporate spinoff, there are no half measures and no such uncertainty — once the division has been spun off, there is no going back. So more like the “Cheers” spinoff “Frasier,” in other words.
But a spinoff isn’t always about trying to create something successful. Sometimes companies have less honorable reasons for spinning off divisions. Sometimes companies will push an underperforming division out into the world, saying it would be better off on its own when the company really just wants rid of it. Sometimes companies will use a spinoff to get rid of a whole bunch of other junk along with the underperforming division: It might pair it with other poor performers and maybe even load it up with debt.
All of which means investors need to be skeptical about buying into a spinoff and vigilant when they’re doing due diligence. Because for every “NCIS” in the world, there are plenty of “Joeys.”
As a nonprofit news organization, our future depends on listeners like you who believe in the power of public service journalism.
Your investment in Marketplace helps us remain paywall-free and ensures everyone has access to trustworthy, unbiased news and information, regardless of their ability to pay.
Donate today — in any amount — to become a Marketplace Investor. Now more than ever, your commitment makes a difference.