Social Security left without a boost

Tamara Keith Aug 28, 2009

Social Security left without a boost

Tamara Keith Aug 28, 2009


TESS VIGELAND: Expecting a big fat raise this year?
OK, stop laughing — I get it. You’re not all CEOs. Given the way things are, most people aren’t even thinking about the possibility of more green in their bank accounts. But if you’re a senior collecting Social Security, not only were you thinking about it, you were probably counting on it.

That is until Social Security officials announced this week that for the first time in more than 30 years, seniors will not get cost of living increases, often referred to as COLA.

From Washington, Tamara Keith has more.

Tamara Keith: Social Security payments normally increase a little bit every year. That’s because the payments are tied to the Consumer Price Index. The CPI measures the cost of things like food and gas and other consumer goods. Thanks to the recession and the dramatic drop in gas prices, the CPI is down. So, next year Social Security payments are expected to stay right where they are.

Barbara LaBelle: I’m not an economist, but I’m sorry that just doesn’t cut it with me.

Barbara LaBelle is 67 years old. She’s retired, lives in Michigan and relies almost entirely on her $900 a month Social Security check. She says her personal consumer price index hasn’t come down.

LaBelle: I go to the grocery store and the prices haven’t decreased. The prices have gone up. Everything goes up in price, but my Social Security doesn’t go up.

And LaBelle says she’s paying more for healthcare. Her co-payments have gone up, so she’s spending as much on health care every month as she is on rent.

Her experience is common for many seniors. Healthcare costs are rising a lot faster than the rate of inflation. Barbara Canelli is president of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare. She says healthcare costs are factored into the CPI. But they’re based on the average American, and seniors spend a lot more on healthcare than the average American.

Barbara Canelli: That’s why seniors get hurt by not having a COLA, because their basic expense, other than their rent or their mortgage, is healthcare.

Seniors who had been counting on extra income from their 401(k)s or equity in their homes have seen their nest eggs shrink. Take Minnesota retiree Douglas Agustin. He’s rationing his retirement saving and relying more heavily on his Social Security check.

Douglas Agustin: I am not living high on the hog.

Agustin says his only indulgences are his pets and the occasional fishing trip.

Agustin: I think I’ve been to two movies in two years. And I don’t eat out much although I might grab something like a Taco Bell where you can get a 69-cent taco.

Social Security advocate Barbara Canelli and groups like the AARP want Congress to either give seniors a small lump sum or approve a cost of living increase, even though the Social Security funding formula doesn’t call for it. But not everyone is convinced that seniors are worse off. Jagadeesh Gokhale is a senior fellow at the conservative Cato Institute.

Jagadeesh Gokhale: On net, I think retirees are coming out ahead.

He points out Social Security recipients got a nearly 6 percent cost of living increase earlier this year and prices on many consumer goods have dropped.

Gokhale: We hear a lot about the senior’s plight, because their lobbies are much more organized and more vocal about their problems.

But that doesn’t mean Congress will be listening when it returns from recess. Lawmakers already have a lot of pressing and pricey matters on their to-do lists, like a healthcare overhaul.

In Washington, I’m Tamara Keith for Marketplace Money.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.