1

Refinance or embrace a shorter mortgage

Question: We're a family of 3, and I'm about 40yrs old. We are considering a refinance of our house to get a better rate. We're fine financially - no risk of default, not underwater, etc. We currently have 20 years left on our existing mortgage, and put $200 into a 529 plan for our daughter who will be in college in 12 yrs. We're fully funding retirement using my 401K... though we might be able to do a little more there (about 225K in my account now - but that's the only account).

I'm wondering if it's better to try and shorten our term to 15 years, so we can be (almost) finished paying when goes to school, OR if we should go with a 30 year term, and put the difference in our monthly payment into her 529. The difference in the 2 options is about $900 a month. Should I consider putting more away for retirement? Lisa, Mansfield, MA

Answer: I like how you're out to build savings. A 15-year mortgage is a good approach to take so long as you're happy with your home and neighborhood.

However, there is another option which will give you additional built-in flexibility for managing your money. Refinance your mortgage to get the lower rate but accelerate the payments on your own.

This way you can turn it into a 12 year mortgage, a 15 year mortgage, or a 20 year mortgage. (Since you have only 20 years left on your mortgage I would prefer that its extinguished at that point.) Yet you can always return to the lower regular payment schedule if it turns put you need the extra money or you have a better use for it.

If you decide to refinance and adopt, say, a 20 year repayment policy rather than a 15 year timetable I would put a priority on boosting retirement savings over setting money aside for college. The reason is that time is increasingly precious resource as you age while your daughter will have a lifetime of earnings ahead of her following graduation. The savings you make now for your retirement will really pay off down the line.

About the author

Chris Farrell is the economics editor of Marketplace Money.
Harry's picture
Harry - Oct 2, 2011

Correct me if I am wrong, Chris, but there is another way to look at this. A lot can happen in 12 years and perhaps you may not need all the money you socked away in 529 after all - but if there is more than you need and you use the excess for anything else it comes with a hefty tax penalty. Otoh, if you pay off your mortgage fully by the time your daughter goes to college, then if there is not enough money in the 529 you own your home and take out a loan based on that to pay for your daughter's college and if there is, then you own your home free and clear! So I would suggest first paying off the mortgage early, then funding your retirement and third putting what you can in the 529.