3
School cost cuts lead to more garbage
A styrofoam lunch tray with entrees, on display in the Nettelhorst Elementary School lunchroom in Chicago, Ill.
To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.
TEXT OF STORY
Kai Ryssdal: For all the focus on the food that goes on school trays, there's more attention being paid now to the trays themselves. The hard plastic trays most of us grew up with are largely a thing of the past. Chicago Public Radio's Linda Lutton reports.
LINDA LUTTON: The students at Waters Elementary School in Chicago plant vegetables behind the school. They have compost bins and separate their lunchtime trash. So it's hard for children here to stomach the Styrofoam trays lunch is served on.
Nine-year-old Alexander Conway is just a little taller than the garbage can where kids toss their trays.
ALEXANDER CONWAY: This is just going to the landfill. So we need to help our environment and get some new plates and not these styrofoam.
Chicago schools use almost a quarter of a million polystyrene trays a day. The kids at Waters figured out that in a year, that's enough trays to pave a path to the moon. But tight school budgets make change unlikely.
Here's schools spokeswoman Monique Bond.
MONIQUE BOND: Everyone wants to do the right thing and have the healthiest choices, the healthiest environment for our students, but for us as a district it all boils down to cost.
Schools can buy 500 foam trays for about $20. Biodegradable trays can cost four times that. Over the years, schools have gotten rid of hard plastic trays to save on labor costs. Many don't have dishwashers or drying racks anymore, so going back to the way things used to be isn't easy.
But some districts are trying. Portland, Ore., is moving all its elementary schools to "permanent ware."
KRISTY OBBINK: The extra expense in paying for our employees to wash those trays will equate to a few hundred thousand dollars.
Kristy Obbink is nutrition services director at Portland Public Schools. Obbink's budget allows for $2.70 per meal. That has to pay for everything, from cheese pizza to employee benefits.
OBBINK: I have to make the really tough decisions as to whether or not to put the money into the food on the plate, or put the money into washing the plates.
And like other school lunch programs across the country, Obbink's budget
is expected to break even.
In Chicago, I'm Linda Lutton for Marketplace.
I had lunch with my first grader the other day and was horrified to see all the children eat off of disposable styrofoam trays, cups and disposable "sporks". How could this possibly be saving the school system the money they say it is and at what horrible cost to the environment?? According to this attached SNF report, it's not.
Being a Florida resident, the first thing I did was install a solar hot water heater and solar panel on my home at minimal cost after rebates, so are the school boards so very ignorant of how to efficiently run a dishwasher here? Long term the numbers don't lie. If they would give up the disposables and get the dishwasher, solar panels and permanent plates, not only would they save quite a bit in the long run, but the children would be learning a valuable lesson while helping keep their world a bit less toxic.
Please see link below which compares disposables to plastic-wares
http://www.schoolnutrition.org/uploadedFiles/School_Nutrition/110_SNFoun...
Turns out plastic compartment trays are the lowest cost option. Just food for thought.
Steve Gluck
United States Dinnerware
Dear Ms. Lutton,
Could you please contact me regarding this story. I am the last domestic manufacturer of plastic school lunch trays and I had a few questions for you if you don't mind.
If Ms. Lutton is not available could someone please forward this message to her or provide her email address.
Thanks.
Steve Gluck
United States Dinnerware
sgluck@prolon.biz
601-456-1763-direct
