The message in the market is... what?

The stock market is taking another nosedive. Economists are cutting their global growth estimates. Investors worry that European banks aren't strong enough to withstand the Mediterranean sovereign debt crisis. Political gridlock is paralyzing fiscal policy in Washington.

The gloom about the economy's prospects is feeding off the declining stock market. We've been trained to look at the trend in stock prices as a reasonably accurate gauge. Policymakers, corporate executives, and ordinary workers need to pay attention to the market's collective judgment. Right?

Well, maybe not. There's no real doubt that the economic fundamentals have taken a turn for the worse. Question is, by how much? A little? A lot? Yes, the stock market seems to be signaling that the odds of another recession are high. But what if the downbeat message in the market is distorted and amplified by meaningless stock trading activity that simply feeds off volatility.In other words, the market is telling us less about the economy and more about high frequency traders.

High-frequency traders use extremely powerful computers and sophisticated algorithms to exploit exceedingly small price movements, buying and selling in fractions of a second. The Wall Street Journal on Aug. 16th noted how high frequency traders are scoring big off market volatility:

High-frequency traders have roughly tripled their stock trades this month, estimates Tabb Group, a markets-research firm in New York. That has boosted their share of overall U.S. stock trading volume to about 65%, up from about 53% during the months before the August turmoil, according to the research firm.>

That's a big share of market trading. Economist Ed Yardeni is convinced that high frequency trading "contributed significantly to the insane volatility of the market over the past two weeks." He quotes from a report by the Brattle Group, an economic and financial consulting firm:

In most HFT strategies, quotes only last for a few micro- or milliseconds at a maximum, and therefore are not actionable by the majority of market participants. There is also evidence that some HFT systems deliberately cancel many of their orders almost immediately after placing them, as they do not intend for the trades to carry through. The false orders are used instead as part of a 'pinging' tactic to discover the price other traders are willing to pay. These practices, known as 'flickering quotes' or 'quote stuffing,' have been claimed to generate an overload of data to market centers, potentially increasing systemic risk.>

Human judgment, however flawed, seems less and less a factor in the stock market. A fascinating paper by Paul David, economic historian at Stanford and Oxford, delves into the risks of computer trading outrunning human judgment and regulatory oversight. It's suggestive--and chilling.

Perhaps we should call it the Skynet Market.

In the Terminator movie series, the military judged humans as too slow and inefficient so the Skynet digital defense system was created. Problem is, the machines took over. I know the news in the market isn't good. I just don't know how much the stock market gyrations reflect a computer-generated mirage and how much the best guesstimate of human judgment trying to pierce the fog of the future. Either way, it isn't a comforting thought.

About the author

Chris Farrell is the economics editor of Marketplace Money.
Log in to post2 Comments

Label Heuer Wrist watches Would be the Best Adornments With regard to Each Guy As well as Woman<br><br>Label Heuer wrist watches carry out significantly. Which are the reason the actual Label Heuer turn out to be therefore well-liked. The actual Label Heuer believes from the accuracy. That is simply the key reason why therefore numerous people choose Label Heuer view.<br><br>TagHeuer brings together the actual features along with reputation as well as accuracy effectively. Label Heuer accomplished an excellent outcome which arranged a typical associated with accuracy how the additional Switzerland view businesses tend to be difficult to create. To exhibit their own plentiful power, Label Heuer offers setup the art gallery to show the actual progressiveness as well as art of the wrist watches from it's head office.<br><br>There are numerous levels associated with reproductive system wrist watches providing on the market. The very best products is actually bunch installed. Since the put together view consists of the best extras that are brought in through Europe using the higher cost. Because of the main reason, the actual item is actually more costly compared to reproductive system 1.<br><br>Another replicate Label Heuer wrist watches that the extras tend to be brought in within Asia {also additionally ,}provide top quality and therefore are very made welcome through lots of individuals. It is cost is gloomier compared to Switzerland view.<br><br>Another kind of reproduction Label Heuer view is created within The far east. In contrast to the actual Switzerland view as well as Japoneses view, the actual things tend to be reduced.<br><br>Top quality replicate wrist watches nearly possess reliable period maintaining capability. Label Heuer view simply has got the reliable period maintaining capability. It is top quality as well as unique style resembles the initial view.<br><br>Because everyone knows, exactly what ornanments match the girl the majority of may be the gemstone. Consequently, Label Heuer utilizes gemstone in order to enhance the actual view in order that it could be more desirable with regard to lady. A few woman be aware both elegance as well as high quality from the view. The actual Label Heuer gemstone view may possibly content material the ladies that like to gather wrist watches or even thoese that adore the actual top quality Switzerland view.<br><br>Label Heuer not just suits with regard to woman {but however}in addition for man. Because it is among the well-known manufacturers which has the actual wise, exact, endurable style as well as beautiful design. Males make use of the view more regularly compared to ladies. Because Label Heuer wrist watches represents development as well as precision, it might be nicely encouraged through males. They've launched wrist watches along with special styles and designs along with respectable workmanship as well as exceptional sturdiness created for numerous sports activities. This established fact which Label Heuer wrist watches possess top quality as well as wise style, {also additionally ,}it obtain a great popularity from it wrist watches.<br><br>Lots of people believe the actual Label Heuer wrist watches tend to be expensive. They likewise have less expensive cost wrist watches wrist watches along with attractive, top quality, as well as fashionable style. Thoese wrist watches consist of different styles of style anddifferent titles or even versions. They've the actual wrist watches that each typeyou might want. A lot of us believe it is not possible for all of us to possess a gemstone view having a wise searching as well as top quality. Do not quit, believe in your self that you could purchase this eventually.<br><br>Overall, Label Heuer wrist watches along with top quality as well as numerous styles tend to be really worth becoming chosen. Bear in mind, before you decide to purchase the Label Heuer wrist watches, you are able to bypass a few shops to be able to buy the view having a logical cost. An additional solution to purchase the view is actually store on the internet. They likewise have their own owm web site that you should understand the info of the products. Numerous people choose purchase Label Heuer view on the internet compared to within the view shops, simply because they may choose the most recent designs using the inexpensive cost. Past which, the internet shops convey more designs and much more colours compared to nomal shops. The web site convey more info, make sure you arrive right here.

Green was able to get behind Bills CB Leodis McKelvin last week, hauling in four receptions for 118 yards Suh is constantly doubled, which singles up fellow interior lineman Corey Williams"The yards have been there, a lot and points as well -- given up a lot of points and yards, which isn't a good thing,<a href="http://www.officialsteelersteamshop.com/lamarr-woodley-jersey-c-15_30.ht... LaMarr Woodley Jersey</a>," Urlacher said FridayWillis relies on NT Isaac Sopoaga to eat ups tons of blocks so he can fly around and make tackles<br><br>JIts been more than a decade since the Lions have been on Monday night footballFirst and foremost,<a href="http://www.officialsteelersteamshop.com/hines-ward-jersey-c-15_33.html">... Hines Ward Jersey</a>, though, I go back with Al Davis to 1954<br><br> Really"It's been blown out of proportion," the Browns' receiver and kick-return extraordinaire told WKRK-FM on Friday With Chad Henne out for the season, the winless Miami Dolphins signed Sage Rosenfels to back up or possibly compete with new starter Matt Moore I just want to make it clear that I'm a football player,<a href="http://www.officialsaintsteamshop.com/darren-sharper-jersey-c-15_28.html... Darren Sharper Jersey</a>, I want to be with a team and be with an organization that will be as committed to me as I will be to them<br><br>Related Articles:

<li><a href="http://www.rdzx.net/xlzx/bbs/boke.asp?pbpf6e486a.showtopic.2717.html" target="_blank">There is no question he is always part of this tea</a></li>


With Generous Support From...