7

Triangle-shaped hot dogs?

There's quite a bit of discussion today about a warning from the American Academy of Pediatrics. Because choking on food is a considerable danger for young children, the Academy wants mandatory labeling about choking hazards. And it suggests some foods like hot dogs should be "redesigned."

More from the statement's lead author:

"We know what shape, sizes and consistencies pose the greatest risk for choking in children and whenever possible food manufacturers should design foods to avoid those characteristics, or redesign existing foods when possible, to change those characteristics to reduce the choking risk...

"Any food that has a cylindrical or round shape poses a risk," he pointed out. Smith said that hot dogs were high on the list of foods that could be redesigned -- perhaps the shape, although he said it would be up to the manufacturers to figure out the specifics.

The hot dog industry's response:

In response to the call for warning labels and hot dog re-engineering, Janet Riley, president of the National Hot Dog & Sausage Council, pointed out that most hot dog packages in the U.S. already advise parents to chop up hot dogs into more easily swallowed pieces.

"As a mother who has fed toddlers cylindrical foods like grapes, bananas, hot dogs and carrots, I 'redesigned' them in my kitchen by cutting them with a paring knife until my children were old enough to manage on their own," she said.

Even when they're old enough, kids can still choke on food. Earlier this month in California, a 13-year-old boy died after eating a hot dog in a bizarre contest:

Noah had joined 12 other boys and girls in a hot dog eating game. It was not a contest to see who could eat the most hot dogs...

Instead, each participant was handed a cooked hot dog with whipped cream on it in a bun. Each child who could finish the odd combination was to receive candy as a prize.

Perhaps this is why doctors believe warning labels are necessary. Because adults hold contests that encourage kids to eat hot dogs with whipped cream. Who wouldn't gag? And for swallowing the whole thing, candy was the prize. Did I mention this was a fundraiser for children in Haiti? It's tragic and nonsensical.

The pediatrician's group says hard candy might also be redesigned so that it's flat instead of round.

Choking is clearly a danger that parents should be aware of, but maybe the doctors' message should be something else entirely.

Matt W's picture
Matt W - Feb 22, 2010

Let's just cover all bases and put the following on anything you eat.

SURGEON GENERAL'S WARNING: Chewing your food before swallowing prevents gagging.

Doug Carleton's picture
Doug Carleton - Feb 23, 2010

What's next. Yesterday on NPR there was an interview with a second or third generation hot-dog maker. Even though the accidents are not a laughing matter, the interview was a hoot. He said something very intersting at the end that I never knew. He said if a parent was really worried about it, feed a child baloney, that's it's almost exactly the same stuff. Could have fooled me.

Heywood Jablome's picture
Heywood Jablome - Feb 26, 2010

Hot dogs (so-called by the layman, the more accurate terms is frankfurter) with whipped cream is a popular dessert in Germany. The author of this article should endeavor to be more global in his (I'm assuming gender based on the appearance of male-pattern baldness but if I am mis-assuming, please forgive me) approach to the world. The earth is not all middle-west-United-States, Norman-Rockwell water-color art, old man and old woman with pitchfork painting but a vast global village. This global village has many choice of desserts, some with hot fudge, some without hot fudge. Shame on this author for being so provincial.

Floyd R. Turbo (American)'s picture
Floyd R. Turbo ... - Feb 26, 2010

Stinking non-American foreignors clogging up our commentary boxes with this stinking, foreign, unAmerican claptrap! Whose ownin' the podium at the Vancover games? We are! Whose winning all the non-stupid sports like curling or that one where you ski and shoot? We are! Freaking Canadians don't know what hit them, you know except hockey which you know they should dominate 'cause they like invented it or something. Whatever. USA! USA! USA! USA! ASU! UXA! YAS!

The Lady Miss Belinda's picture
The Lady Miss B... - Feb 26, 2010

Can't we just all get along? Why U be hatin' on the German guy? We're all just men walking around on this planet together - you know, dressin', stylin, being fierce and watching Wendy Williams on the T V-ouse together. Have we learned nothing from Tyra?!

janet's picture
janet - Feb 22, 2010

And, how about a warning tatooed on children's foreheads....

"Children should be supervised when eating"

Matt W's picture
Matt W - Feb 22, 2010

@janet, The "when eating" part could be left off. :)