Could nuclear fusion solve the climate crisis?

Stephen Beard Jan 10, 2022
Heard on:
Tokamak's latest nuclear fusion reactor, the ST40, which emulates the way stars generate energy, CEO Chris Kelsall says. Photo courtesy Tokamak Energy

Could nuclear fusion solve the climate crisis?

Stephen Beard Jan 10, 2022
Heard on:
Tokamak's latest nuclear fusion reactor, the ST40, which emulates the way stars generate energy, CEO Chris Kelsall says. Photo courtesy Tokamak Energy

A gray, anonymous-looking building on an industrial estate south of the English city of Oxford seems an understated setting for this story. For this is where a group of technicians has been creating some of the hottest temperatures on planet Earth in the quest for an unlimited, carbon-free, relatively inexpensive and utterly transformative source of energy.

Chris Kelsall, CEO of Tokamak Energy. ”This is the final frontier. The endgame solution.” (Photo by Stephen Beard)
Chris Kelsall, CEO of Tokamak Energy: ”This is the final frontier, the endgame solution.” (Photo by Stephen Beard)

Tokamak Energy is one of dozens of research projects around the world that are working on nuclear fusion, a technology that involves fusing rather than splitting atoms, as with nuclear fission. Harnessing the power of the sun is how Tokamak CEO Chris Kelsall described the process, for this is precisely how stars create energy.

“The light that we see coming into our house every day, the starlight that we see at night, the light reflected from the moon — that’s all from fusion reactions out in the universe,” Kelsall said.   

Research into fusion has been going on for decades, but the need to mitigate climate change by switching to carbon-free energy sources has brought new urgency to the work. It is now a momentous effort.

“This is the final frontier, the endgame solution — for all time, for humankind,“ Kelsall said. “We are producing a reliable, safe, clean source of decarbonized energy. It’s going to be such an exciting journey that in fact has no limits.” 

The journey sounds dangerous, though. The technology at work in his company’s Oxfordshire plant seems, on the face of it, pretty fearsome.

The approach is called magnetic confinement and involves a large, cylindrical machine containing powerful magnets. The machine or reactor is known as a tokamak, a Russian acronym that stands for toroidal chamber with magnetic coils.” Inside this device, hydrogen atoms are forced to fuse at incredibly high temperatures.

Inside the ST40 fusion reactor. (Photo courtesy of Tokamak Energy)
Inside the ST40 fusion reactor. (Photo courtesy Tokamak Energy)

“We’re operating at 50 million degrees centigrade,” said Graham Dunbar, project manager of the ST40 reactor. “And our next milestone is 100 million degrees centigrade.” 

Graham Dunbar, project manager. ”There is no possibility of meltdown.” (Photo by Stephen Beard)
Graham Dunbar, project manager: ”There is no possibility of meltdown.” (Photo by Stephen Beard)

That would be the equivalent of 212 million degrees Fahrenheit. A scary number, but Dunbar insisted that the device is perfectly safe.

“The magnetic field contains the heat, so the outside of ST40 does not get hot. You can put your hand on the outside of ST40,” he said.

Unlike with nuclear fission, the radiation emitted by this process dissipates in about 20 minutes, so there is no problem with nuclear waste. And there’s no potentially uncontrollable chain reaction.

“If there’s any disturbance in the magnetic field, the plasma collapses safely. There is no possibility of meltdown. It’s inherently safe,” Dunbar said.

It’s also potentially inexpensive since the fuel — hydrogen — is the 10th most abundant element on Earth and the fusion process releases four times as much energy as fission.

Kelsall hopes to have a commercial demonstrator device within a decade and to be selling reactors globally within a decade after that.

“We’re seeking to develop fusion power plants for deployment in the late 2030s and early 2040s,” he said.   

But enormous technical challenges have yet to be overcome. Fusion research projects have been going on for more than half a century and so far they’ve all generated less energy than it took to cause the fusion in the first place.

This technology does not enjoy universal acceptance and support.  

Steve Thomas, retired professor of energy Ppolicy and fusion skeptic.
Steve Thomas, retired professor of energy policy and fusion skeptic. (Photo courtesy Steve Thomas)

Steve Thomas, a retired professor of energy policy from Greenwich University, is a fusion skeptic.

“The breakthrough has always been just over the horizon, and that’s where it still seems to be,” Thomas said.

The mantra has always been the same, he said: “In another 10 years or so, we’ll have a commercial device.”

“Maybe that will be the case this time around,” Thomas added. “But I’m skeptical after so many broken promises over the past 50 or so years.”   

Fusion supporters, however, point to recent developments in the United States, where late last year the Massachusetts Institute of Technology announced that it had created the world’s most powerful magnetic field of its type, and that this paved the way to completing the world’s first commercial fusion demonstrator device by 2025.

At Tokamak Energy, CEO Kelsall also stressed that private investors are voting with their dollars. They have poured more than $160 million into his company and almost $2 billion into MIT’s spinoff company — Commonwealth Fusion Systems.

“Investors are realizing that fusion needs to be looked at. It needs to be investigated, and if they don’t have a seat at the table, there’s a very real risk that they’re going to miss out on the next Google,” he said.  

An international race is underway to crack the fusion conundrum and become that “energy Google.” While Kelsall conceded that “there are some excellent peer companies in the U.S. with very strong funding,” he said that Tokamak Energy’s reactor can offer a competitive alternative.

He clearly believes this is a race that he and his team in Oxfordshire can win.

We’re here to help you navigate this changed world and economy.

Our mission at Marketplace is to raise the economic intelligence of the country. It’s a tough task, but it’s never been more important.

In the past year, we’ve seen record unemployment, stimulus bills, and reddit users influencing the stock market. Marketplace helps you understand it all, will fact-based, approachable, and unbiased reporting.

Generous support from listeners and readers is what powers our nonprofit news—and your donation today will help provide this essential service. For just $5/month, you can sustain independent journalism that keeps you and thousands of others informed.