Can a credit card be sexist?

Erika Beras and Sabri Ben-Achour Nov 11, 2019
HTML EMBED:
COPY
Jennifer Bailey, vice president of Apple Pay, speaks during an Apple product launch event at the Steve Jobs Theater at Apple Park on March 25 in Cupertino, California. Michael Short/Getty Images

Can a credit card be sexist?

Erika Beras and Sabri Ben-Achour Nov 11, 2019
Jennifer Bailey, vice president of Apple Pay, speaks during an Apple product launch event at the Steve Jobs Theater at Apple Park on March 25 in Cupertino, California. Michael Short/Getty Images
HTML EMBED:
COPY

Apple has been busy diversifying, expanding into media with the creation of its Apple TV service and launching its own credit card, a collaboration with Mastercard and Goldman Sachs. 

But the card is being criticized for discriminating against women. It started with a software engineer who said on Twitter that the Apple card allowed him a much larger credit line that his wife without good reason.

Others came forward in agreement, among them, Steve Wozniak, co-founder of Apple, who said his wife — with whom he shares credit cards, bank accounts and assets — had the same experience.

The potential cause is a computer algorithm, one the New York State Department of Financial Services has said it will investigate.

The department is already investigating for bias a UnitedHealth algorithm that allegedly caused black patients to receive less comprehensive care than white patients

How credit limits are normally set

“The biggest factor here is gonna be your credit report,” said Jill Gonzalez, WalletHub analyst. “That’s obviously where the largest wealth of information on you is — things like how on time you are in paying your bill, how long the length of your credit history.”

Another big factor in determining credit limit: how much a person owes compared to how much they make.

But then there’s a whole other layer of information that can be used. How long does the bank or credit card company think you are going to stick with them? Are you brand loyal?

“Apple obviously has lots of information about a lot of people,” said Jonathan Glowacki, a principal at Milliman, a quantitative consulting firm for the financial industry.

He said there’s a risk that sometimes a variable might unfairly target a particular group. For example, a ZIP code, which a bank could use to determine creditworthiness. 

“ZIP code could be a proxy variable for an income of a given region. However, it also could be correlated with protected groups like race and national origin,” Glowacki said.

The exact recipe though? We don’t know.

“Issuer to issuer, it’s kind of a secret sauce that is ever changing,” Gonzalez said.

The fact that people have to guess what exactly is going on is both frustrating — some of those on Twitter who complained about Apple’s credit limit determining system said even customer service representatives couldn’t explain it — and part of the reason why the New York State Department of Financial Services is investigating the Apple Card.

“This is what’s known as a black box, where there’s no visibility into how these credit decisions are being made. And when consumers are applying for financial services and products, they’re entitled as a matter of consumer protection to understand how these decisions are being made,” said Linda A. Lacewell, New York state superintendent of financial services.

In a statement, Goldman said it bases credit limits on individuals’ particular qualifications:

“As with any other individual credit card, your application is evaluated independently. We look at an individual’s income and an individual’s creditworthiness, which includes factors like personal credit scores, how much debt you have, and how that debt has been managed. Based on these factors, it is possible for two family members to receive significantly different credit decisions.”

Goldman also said it does not take gender into account when setting credit limits.

Correction (Nov. 13, 2019): A previous version of this story misspelled Jill Gonzalez’s name.

As a nonprofit news organization, our future depends on listeners like you who believe in the power of public service journalism.

Your investment in Marketplace helps us remain paywall-free and ensures everyone has access to trustworthy, unbiased news and information, regardless of their ability to pay.

Donate today — in any amount — to become a Marketplace Investor. Now more than ever, your commitment makes a difference.