🖤 Donations of all sizes power our public service journalism Give Now
 Leicester, a city in England, reacts to Leicester City Football Club's Premier League Title success on Tuesday. Matthew Lewis/Getty Images

Leicester City: ‘Every bookmaker is crying out in pain’

Marketplace Staff May 3, 2016
 Leicester, a city in England, reacts to Leicester City Football Club's Premier League Title success on Tuesday. Matthew Lewis/Getty Images

From our partners at BBC Business:

The betting industry is licking its financial wounds.

“In the history of betting, certainly since it was legalized in 1961, a [single event] winner with odds of 5,000-1 has never happened,” said Simon Clare from the betting firm Coral. “Every bookmaker is crying out in pain.”

“That’s a barometer of what Leicester have done and just how amazing this win is,” he added.

Jessica Bridges from rival firm Ladbrokes agrees.

“This is the biggest sporting upset of all time. We’ve all got a bit of egg on our face,” she said.

Bookmakers have been cheering Leicester’s success, whilst simultaneously putting their hands in their collective pockets.

Something special

Betting firm William Hill has paid out more than £20,000 ($29,109) to 39-year-old carpenter, Lee Herbert. He was one of the canny few to take up the now-famous odds of 5,000-1 for his team to win. Although he has been a supporter since he was 10, he doesn’t usually put his money where his heart is.

“I really enjoyed the first half of the season, the second half just got harder and harder, ” he said.”I would feel sick watching them play.”

But, mulling over their prospects on a camping holiday he found he was encouraged by the team’s performance at the end of the last season, and, taking a shine to the appointment of Claudio Ranieri as manager, he decided to put down the £5 ($7.28) bet at for his team to win.

“I thought, they’re going to do something special this season,” he said.

Eventually, he cashed out £2 ($2.91) of his £5($7.28) bet, making £5,600 ($8,150.58), but left the £3 ($4.37) remainder in place, which eventually won him £15,000 ($21,831.90). A party is in order this weekend — as well as house hunting with his new deposit.

Bookmakers estimate the industry as a whole will have lost around £20m ($29 million). Yet, they sound almost as exhilarated and excited by Leicester City’s win as the lucky punters and the fans, because although they are facing steep losses as a result, for them it’s a great story.

Form ignored

The bookmakers were much slower than the punters to believe that Leicester could win the title. The problem was not so much the long odds at the start of the season, but the fact that they were so slow to respond to Leicester’s success. At Christmas, when the Foxes had won 10 games in a row, the odds were still quite high, in Coral’s case they were still at 33-1 in December. It wasn’t until Leicester beat Manchester City 3-1 in February that they became favorites to win.

“The bookies were just ignoring their form. The punters started to believe but not the bookies,” said Clare. “We’ve never lost money like this — it’s the biggest hit we’ve ever taken. In a way, it’s a beautiful wake up call. It’s an amazing moment.”

Claudio Ranieri, manager of Leicester City, smiles after the Barclays Premier League match between Manchester United and Leicester City at Old Trafford on May 1 in Manchester, England.

And there is a sound reason they are not downcast at their losses. Next year they’re expecting a great flood of new bets as fans from Burnley to Bournemouth hope that their team will “do a Leicester”.

The odds on a Watford or a West Brom win are slight of course. Leicester’s success was a “perfect storm of the right manager, right players, few injuries, no playing in Europe and the big teams underperforming,” said Dale Tempest from online betting firm Skybet. The company, which sponsors the three divisions below the Premier League, has a particularly large base of Leicester supporters and is therefore one of the companies that stands to lose the most — in the region of £5m ($7.3 million).

Numbers game

Interestingly, the bookmakers seem to think that the chances of Leicester being relegated are greater than them winning again. Tempest said that’s because the stakes have been raised — there will be tempting offers for the top players, the big teams are looking to change managers and they’ll have to play in Europe.

So has it made the industry more cautious?

Ladbrokes said no more 5,000-1 odds for the Premier League, Coral said it will be much more cautious. But Skybet have got 5,000-1 odds for Burnley to win the Premier League, who have just won the Championship and will be promoted next season. Already, 888 people have placed their bets — meaning that if they win Skybet stand to lose £7m ($10.2 million). However, Tempest said the company will be quicker to slash the odds should the team start performing, a sentiment echoed by all the companies.

But William Hill’s Graham Sharpe says this is a numbers game. The chances of Leicester winning were that slim and they would probably do the same again — and the next 4,999 times they’ll be right. He likens it to the jockey Frankie Detorri riding the winning horse in all seven races at Ascot in 1996 — an unheard of feat. He remembers the stunned haze surrounding the bookies and their £40m($58.2 million) loss.
But he said, it was so unlikely, that they all agreed they’d probably do the same again.

“This time we hold our hands up and say well done. But [Claudio] Ranieri, don’t do it again,” he said.

And as for fan Lee Herbert — will he be doing it again?

“This is it for me. I mean… it’s not going to happen again, so why carry on?”

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.