What have you always wondered about the economy? Tell us
Ask Money

Borrow to buy?

Chris Farrell Oct 28, 2008

Question: The stock market meltdown that we’re facing today looks like one of the best stock buying opportunities that I am likely to face in my lifetime. I don’t have a lot of spare cash, so I’m considering borrowing some money to buy some mutual funds. I’m 34, have a stable job in a good company. I have a 30-year fixed mortgage and a HELOC that currently offers an interest rate of 5.25%. I don’t have much debt other than a car loan that I’m paying down. I am going to school part time on a student loan. I’m thinking about taking $4,000 or $5,000 out of the HELOC and buying an index fund or a financial sector fund. What do you think? Patrick, Atlanta GA

Answer: Big mistake. Yes, stocks may offer a high potential return, but only by taking on a considerable amount of risk. Remember, stock market returns are not guaranteed, but you will have to meet the interest payments on your loan no matter what–or put your house at risk. Borrowing on your home to invest in the stock market is always a bad bet. And in the current environment people need to be paying down debt, not adding to it.

That said, you could be right about the stock market. I don’t know when or where the stock market will hit bottom, but there is value in the market. And there was a spectacular raly today of some 11%.

Warren Buffet, the famous stock picker, is buying. So is Marty Whitman, another well-known value investor of Third Avenue Management. Jeremy Grantham, the legendary investor at Boston-based GMO told Business Week that stocks are now cheaper than they’ve been since 1987. “You are looking at the best prices in 20 years, and you should be making 7% to 8% to 9% real [inflation-adjusted] returns,” he said. “The last time I was this optimistic was in the summer of 1982.”

These three long-time investors have built sterling money making reputations over a long period of time. Here’s what Jack Bogle, the octogenarian founder of the mutual fund giant Vanguard, told me in a recent interview: “We can, however, look ahead and make reasonable predictions. In the bond market, we know with 90% probability that return in the next 10 years will be 4.5% to 5%. That’s the historical number. If we have huge inflation and a Great Depression, and lots of bonds default–this is why I like Treasuries–then that’s something else again. In stocks, we know the sources of stock returns. Dividend yield is almost 2.5%, and earnings growth from these levels ought to be 6% over the next decade. That’s an 8.5% return.”

Grantham notes that when bubbles burst markets historically overcorrect by a lot. Your idea is a reasonable bet. But don’t borrow the money. Use cash.

As a nonprofit news organization, our future depends on listeners like you who believe in the power of public service journalism.

Your investment in Marketplace helps us remain paywall-free and ensures everyone has access to trustworthy, unbiased news and information, regardless of their ability to pay.

Donate today — in any amount — to become a Marketplace Investor. Now more than ever, your commitment makes a difference.