11

Overwhelmed by check-out-line charity

Charity coupons in a check-out line at a Whole Foods store in New York City.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

TEXT OF STORY

Kai Ryssdal: Tell me if this has happened to you recently at the supermarket. You unload your basket onto the conveyor belt, browse the tabloids as you wait for the cashier, and then that cashier hits you up for a donation while he's ringing up your groceries. It's tough to get through your shopping these days without being asked to give to one thing or another. A dollar here and a dollar there can really add up for what are often worthy causes. But Michael May explains that there are some hidden costs.


DAVID FICKECK: Would you like to make a donation to the KEYE food drive today? They're a $1, $5 donation, or you can pick a bag over here we can gladly scan for you.

That's David Fickeck, a cashier and store director at the Randall's supermarket in Austin, Texas. He does more than ring up groceries. He's a fundraiser.

Randall's supermarket is owned by Safeway, which does four national charity drives each year in its more than 1500 stores. The regional chains, like Randall's, can elect to do other drives as well, like this one benefiting the food bank. Connie Yates is director of public affairs for Randall's.

CONNIE Yates: It's very important to give back to the community. It's very important to be involved in charities that matter to our customers.

The drive raises $15,000, and about 10,000 pounds of food. Kerri Qunell is with the Capital Area Food Bank. She says Randall's was the first supermarket to do a checkout charity drive in Austin.

KERRI Qunell: Since then there have been other programs that have blossomed in our community and across the country to replicate that. So it is becoming a more popular and more convenient way for grocery shoppers to be able to donate to their local food bank.

And all sorts of other charities. That can put pressure on workers, who have to do the asking. Ron Lind is the president of UFCW local 5, a union that represents supermarket employees. He told me that workers have complained about being pressured to solicit. And when I asked some Randall's shoppers what they thought of the checkout charity drive, they were divided.

Emily Hampton gives at the register, but doesn't like being confronted every time she shops.

EMILY HAMPTON: Yeah, it does really put you on the spot. And when you say no, the people around you, at the back of the line, I'm thinking, they don't know how often I'm here! We shop at Randall's quite a bit.

Last year, Safeway raised more than $50 million for causes like Breast Cancer, and the Special Olympics. Safeway's executives choose which charities the chain will support. For instance, Safeway's Executive Vice President Larree Renda is also a vice president of the Muscular Dystrophy Association. The grocery chain raised $10 million last year for the charity.

Randall's offers some choice. It allows shoppers to link their rewards card to their favorite charity. And at the end of the year, Randall's will make a donation equal to 1 percent of what was spent on the card. Connie Yates again.

Yates: It's our money, our contribution that we are making, but our customers tell us what matters to them.

But to give, they must shop at Randall's. Stacy Palmer is the editor of The Chronicle of Philanthropy. She says check-out charity programs have become popular during the recession.

Stacy Palmer: Certainly any effort to tie charitable giving to shopping is a growing trend, in part because retailers want to find a way to persuade people to buy.

Palmer says checkout fundraising gives charities access to millions of potential givers. But she says there are drawbacks.

PALMER: When you make a donation in response to direct mail appeal or a telephone thing, they can call you back, they can ask you again and again. And that's really how charities raise a lot of money. So the downside of this for the charity is that they don't have a way to reach you again.

That is, until you need more groceries.

In Austin, I'm Michael May for Marketplace.

Pages

Rick McGuire's picture
Rick McGuire - Oct 15, 2010

I avoid Safeway for 2 reasons. 1st. Their Safeway card requires you to give your personal information for a discount off the regular price. Well even after I give them that info for their discount card, I am still paying
more than than the other store down the road for the same items.... What a deal. 2nd. Is the charitable contribution request every time I go through the line. How much is Safeway charging for managing/collecting for the charity? 10%, 30%, 40%??? Haven't found a charity that does not keep a portion for themselves. The other thing is every time I go through the line and say no.. they are publicly causing me defamation of character... IE making it appear to my neighbors in line that I am a tight wad, cheap, selfish, when I choose to actually donate to my church where I know the money is used properly.
I don't personally bother with making it a tax exemption, because I feel that means I am not truly making a donation, I am looking for a return on my charity from Uncle Sam... which degrades my joy of donating without expectation of something in return. So I shop down the street where they don't bilk me before and after I give them my personal information, and the don't defame me in front of others.

John Williams's picture
John Williams - Apr 30, 2010

Hi. I'm curious, does anyone know "for sure" that Safeway takes the whole tax deduction from the charity contribution? I mean, is that even legal for them to do? Does anyone know?

Linda Davidson's picture
Linda Davidson - Apr 21, 2010

OK, I read the other comments here. The smart people have it figured out: Safeway gets a tax deduction for the money it collects from it's willing shoppers who are intimidated into donating to the current charity. Do those shoppers get a receipt with the non-profit organization's ID number and a statement that "no goods or services were given in exchange for the donation"? If not, they can't deduct this from their taxes like Safeway tells them they can. Check your IRS booklet.... Donate directly to charitable organizations and let Safeway contribute some of it's PROFITS (not yours).

Glenn Robinson's picture
Glenn Robinson - Oct 20, 2009

Williams-Sonoma gives 85% of every dollar to the charity. Safeway says that information is proprietary. Whole Foods didn't reply to my email.

Heidi Krause's picture
Heidi Krause - Oct 14, 2009

This got me thinking...

Now I know why my company pressures it's employees so much to give to United Way - they get a friggin' tax deduction on my dime! And it's not like a new employee can say no.

Catherine Adams's picture
Catherine Adams - Oct 14, 2009

Count me among the cynical and annoyed. The company gets the benefits from the donation, and I'm subjected to a refined form of panhandling. I've taken to avoiding stores where this sort of thing goes on, in keeping with my philosophy of never rewarding behavior that I find objectionable.

Lisa Anderson's picture
Lisa Anderson - Oct 13, 2009

Very interesting piece on check-out charity, but you missed the biggest reason corporations like Safeway do this - they get 100% of the tax benefit from the charitable donations funded by their customers. So you're reducing their tax bill with every dollar "you" donate - it's all given in their corporation's name.

David Robinson's picture
David Robinson - Oct 13, 2009

I do feel put upon when asked to donate in the check-out line. My response? "No thank you, but THANK YOU for asking!" said with cheery over-enthusiasm. Everybody's happy.

Ken Freeman's picture
Ken Freeman - Oct 13, 2009

Is there more to the story? How does the store post the donations to their books? How does the $50 Million in donations by Safeway affect their books? Larree Renda is certainly feeling satisfaction with helping the Muscular Dystrophy Association and she is honored with the MDA Directors' Award. She is also the honorary VP for the MDA and will go on the Telethon to present a check to Jerry Lewis. So, does Safeway get a big tax deduction and Ms. Renda a lot of recognition for what is really your and my donations? I hate to be so cynical, but I always try to see the total picture.

Jonathan Blum's picture
Jonathan Blum - Oct 13, 2009

What I've always wanted to know is whether companies are obtaining a tax credit from their customers' donations.

Pages