24

homebuyer tax credit

Question: My husband and I just bought our first home in South Minneapolis this past fall. Since then, I have heard a lot of talk about the IRS Federal Tax Rebate for first time home buyers that is being offered this year. I know that we qualify for the full amount of the rebate ($7500) but I am concerned about the provision to pay it all back in the remaining lump sum in the event we sell in the future. Is there a way to take less than the full amount or is this interest free government loan just too good not to pass up in its entirety? Christine, Minneapolis, MN

Answer: Thanks for the question. I hadn't looked very closely at the $7500 tax credit for first-time homebuyers. You've forced me to look at it more closely and, as far as I can see, it's a better deal than I thought.

Like all tax law today, there are quite a few wrinkles. (The IRS has a lot of good information here.) Here are the highlights:

*It's really an interest free 15-year loan. You claim the credit on your federal income tax form. The tax credit is equal to 10% of the qualified home purchase price, and tops out at $7500.

*You don't have to start repaying the loan for the first two years of homeownership. After that, you send the government $500 a year. If you sell the house before you have repaid the loan you pay it from the gains. No gain? The loan is forgiven.

*To qualify you have to buy on or after April 9, 2008 and before July 1, 2009. (Keep those dates in mind!). The purchase date is defined as the closing day. A first-time homebuyer is defined as someone who hasn't owned a home for 3 years preceding the closing.

*The income limits on adjusted gross income is $75,000 and less for single filers and $150,000 for married joint filers. For income above that a partial credit is available. Anyone with an adjusted gross income of more then $95,000 for single filers and $170,000 for married filers doesn't qualify.

The standard rule of taxes applies here: If taking the credit improves your finances then take advantage of Uncle Sam's offer. And for most people I think the credit will be a good deal.

Additional thoughts, anyone?

Here is an update. It's from a look at President Barack Obama's economic recovery plan as it was reported out of the House Ways and Means Committee. The analysis is by CCH, a Wolters Kluwer business.

New Rules for First-time Homebuyer Credit

The proposed legislation modifies the first-time homebuyer credit that was signed into law last year, removing a requirement that the $7,500 credit be repaid over 15 years, but the waiver applies only to houses purchased in 2009 and before the expiration of the credit on July 1. On the other hand, those who take the credit will have to repay the entire amount if they sell their homes within three years of purchase.

Under current law, those who purchased homes between April 9 and December 31, 2008, can claim the credit on their 2008 return, but must repay it over 15 years, beginning with their tax return two years after purchase. If they sell the home, they must repay the entire credit, but only up to the amount of their gain on the sale.

"Frankly, the distinction between 2008 and 2009 purchases is puzzling," Luscombe said. "It seems strange for the people who bought a home in December 2008 to be treated so differently from those who do so in January, 2009, so I wouldn't be surprised if somewhere along the line someone will take a second look at this."

About the author

Chris Farrell is the economics editor of Marketplace Money.

Pages

Malisa's picture
Malisa - Feb 5, 2009

I also bought my first house Jan 8,2008 and i think this is so stupid that i don't qualify for the credit just because i bought 3 months before. I emailed the congressman, senator and the white house. Everyone needs to complain about this. It is not fair!!!!

Richard's picture
Richard - Feb 5, 2009

I have a coworker who is looking into buying a home. For this example, lets say her total taxes equal $10,000. With this $15,000 tax credit, will she get the $10,000 refunded back, plus her original refund? Without the original refund? Will the credit actually push past the total amount paid, crediting her with $15,000 plus her original refund? $15,000 without the refund? The price of the home she buys could hinge on the amount of cash that may be coming back from this. I guess the basic question is, does a tax credit count as refunded cash even beyond the total tax paid?

cris adams's picture
cris adams - Feb 4, 2009

what about this proposed 15,000 creidt...will it be avaliable to 2008 purchasers or just 2009 purchases?

Chris Farrell's picture
Chris Farrell - Feb 4, 2009

As of right now, to qualify you have to buy on or after April 9, 2008 and before July 1, 2009.

Pargolo's picture
Pargolo - Feb 4, 2009

Are there income limits on the new 15000 tax credit?

Richard's picture
Richard - Feb 5, 2009

I read the proposed amendment and from what I saw, they are keeping the $7500 for homes purchased in 2008, but "sunsetting" the ones in 2009. The 2008 bill says any home purchased april 08 through July 1st 09. The proposed amendment would remove those dates and insert a new $15000 tax credit for homes purchased between January 1st 09 through 1 year after the date the stimulus is signed. This does not eliminate the ability to use the $7500 credit, but it does beg the question of fairness. Say someone closed on December 31st, 2008. They get a $7500 interest free loan. But close on January 1st, 2009 and you have a $15000 tax credit that doesn't have to be paid back! (Assuming you live there for 2 years)
As a first time homebuyer in June 2008, I will watch with great interest to see if they amend that to take over the previous "$7500" bill or if they leave us hanging. Either way I'm not dissatisfied, but it is disheartening to know that if I had waited 6 months I could have saved $15,000.

Chris Farrell's picture
Chris Farrell - Feb 5, 2009

I agree with your reading of the bill. Thanks. There's no final word yet since it's still up for negotiation.

Will's picture
Will - Feb 4, 2009

Chris-

I am nervous about not getting my $7500 credit with the new ammendment. The more I read it sounds like if this is signed that that credit will be wiped out and those of us that bought in 2008 will be left in the cold. Question, if this is the case do I need to file my taxes ASAP to claim the $7500 before this bill is signed? They keep using the word "sunset" in saying that the new ammendment will "sunset" the former $7500 credit. HELP!!???? I am really really counting on that money.

Dustin's picture
Dustin - Feb 4, 2009

Would it matter if you already claimed the 7500 version? Or will I be entitled to the difference on my 2009 tax return?

Hythyr's picture
Hythyr - Feb 5, 2009

Hi-
I bought my house on Jan 2, 2008. But did not make a Mortgage payment until March 1, 2008. This "$7,500 LOAN" only applies to people who bought after April 8, 2008. WHY??? I am still a first time home buyer and bought my home in 2008. What does it matter that i bought mine in the first quarter of the year instead of the 2nd quarter to the end of the year.

Pages