4

What just happened in Cyprus? An explainer

A man uses an ATM machine of the Bank Of Cyprus on March 24, 2013 in Limassol, Cyprus.

The Cyprus affair is a brutal reminder of the fact that when you “save” your money by putting it in a bank, you’re not really “saving” it at all: You’re lending it.

The bank borrows from you at a certain rate of interest, and then turns around and lends the same money out at a greater rate of interest. Well, not all of it. It keeps a wee bit of money on hand so that when we want to do a bit of shopping, we can get cash out of the ATM.

The Cypriot banks did two things. First, they offered depositors really good rates of interest -- as high as 4.75 percent for long-term accounts -- which attracted not only gaggles of old Cypriot ladies, but also hordes of foreigners.

How could the banks afford to pay such great rates? By investing the money from those “savers” in something that itself paid really great rates of interest: Greek government bonds.

When Greece got bailed out, the value of the bonds was cut in half. But that wasn’t all: The fat interest rate that those bonds were paying was also cut -- to just 3.5 percent.

That meant Cyprus’ banks had a lot less money coming in the door. But they still had to pay their depositors -- and in some cases they’re paying depositors more than they’re getting from the bonds.

In other words, the Cypriot banks are deep in debt, and they’re not making enough money to make their interest payments. They’re on the verge of going bust.

For help, they turned first to their European neighbors, who agreed to lend them some cash. They’ve now got more money coming in the door, but it’s not enough. Now they need to attack the problem at the other end, by reducing the amount they owe.

Who do they owe money to? The depositors.

Now, some of those depositors are protected -- accounts under 100,000 Euros are insured -- so you can’t touch them. But the other accounts?

Whack.

Cyprus is taking a big chunk of the money in those accounts -- around 30 percent.

The banks are a bit like the patriarch of a large family who has taken a huge pay cut. His family consists of a bunch of children, aged anywhere between 5- and 25-years-old, and now he's struggling to feed everyone. He gets a loan from his uncle, but it’s not enough. Something’s gotta give! He can’t stop feeding  the little kids. But the over 18s? Sorry boys and girls. From now on, 30 percent less soup for you.

The 30 percent "tax" on those big accounts does two things: First, it brings money into the door of the banks, giving them more money to operate with. Second, it reduces the amount of interest they have to pay to those account holders each month.

Feelings are running high, and two things could happen here. The adult offspring -- the depositors who are getting whacked in this case -- may decide to take their business elsewhere. And the little kids -- the small depositors -- may lose trust in the system and the banks. Sure their money is safe for now. But what about tomorrow? They may decide their money’s safer elsewhere. Maybe in their mattresses. Maybe offshore.

Either way, that’ll mean big problems, for Cyprus and its banks.

About the author

Paddy Hirsch is the Senior Producer, Personal Finance at Marketplace and the creator and host of the Marketplace Whiteboard. Follow Paddy on Twitter @paddyhirsch and on facebook at www.facebook.com/paddyhirsch101
Scott Hagaman's picture
Scott Hagaman - Mar 30, 2013

Sorry, Paddy - I still have a few questions. I never realized a bank could decide who to pay back and how much to pay back. I kinda figured that if they can't pay their debts, they have to declare bankruptcy. As for the smaller depositors, again, I figured the bank would have to treat them like everybody else. Or perhaps better said, a bankruptcy judge would have to treat them like everybody else. I just figured that the Cypriot Government (which is funded by the Cypriot people) would be on the hook for making up the difference for the small depositors - which is little comfort for the Cypriot poor, whose taxes have to bail out the smaller number of Cypriots who have 100K accounts! But if the small depositors get preferential treatment by the bank, then that lets the Cypriot Government off the hook for insuring them. To me, this means that the Cypriot Government never insured them with money, but with extortion, intervening with the bank on the behalf of the smaller depositors, to force the bank to pay them in full. So, how does the Cypriot Government extort the banks, and why do larger depositors (the Russian Mafia, no less), roll over with this unequal treatment? Thanks.

Trinigirl's picture
Trinigirl - Mar 28, 2013

I have to agree with the previous comments; you have made this Cyprus affair easy to understand. I read about 10 Cyprus stories today and after reading your article, I have learnt alot and am now aware of what is really taking place there. I have also gained some financial wisdom from your article.
Thank you Paddy.

MrQ's picture
MrQ - Mar 26, 2013

Thank you Paddy for taking a complicated story and making it easy to understand. Another example of good insight, depth of reporting at the expense of major media not doing their job. Well done.

amoore5000's picture
amoore5000 - Mar 25, 2013

Finally, after reams of stories about Cyprus' woes, an explainer that makes sense of it all. Well done.