Sour grapes? An English county’s wine wins a special status, but a neighboring county complains.
Share Now on:
Once an international laughingstock, English wine now goes from strength to strength, thanks largely to climate change. Rising temperatures, especially in the south, have hugely improved the quantity and quality of English vineyards’ output.
In the latest sign of the growing regard for this once-maligned product, white wine (sparkling and still) from the southern county of Sussex has just been awarded a Protected Designation of Origin, or PDO — a kind of trademark for agricultural produce.
Sussex wineries are celebrating, but at least one vineyard owner from the neighboring county of Kent is not so happy.
This PDO, awarded by the British government and enforced against foreign producers through trade agreements, means that wines can be labeled “Sussex” only if they have been grown in that county, made in accordance with local tradition and aged for at least two years.
This gives it the same level of protection as the world’s preeminent sparkling wine, Champagne. It emphasizes the importance in winemaking of what the French call “terroir”: the climate, soil, elevation and other physical attributes of a particular vineyard.
“This is the perfect place to make wine,“ said Art Tukker, standing among his vines in the Tinwood Estate, near Chichester in Sussex on the south coast of England.
“On our south side is the ocean, which gives us the temperate climate, which saves us from the frost in the springtime. And we have the ideal soil — lots of flint for drainage and half a meter of pure white chalk. It produces a very fresh, very mineral, very clean-tasting wine,” Tukker said. “We’ve got a very special place, a special soil to produce these world-class sparkling wines here.”
These qualities helped Sussex wine win the PDO, a terrific marketing boost. It has Tukker hoping that he and his fellow winemakers might one day challenge the global dominance of Champagne, the world’s most famous fizz. Could people one day say, “Let’s celebrate! Let’s have a glass of Sussex!”?
“That’s the plan,” he said. “Champagne wasn’t built in a year. Rome wasn’t built in a year. But that’s the ultimate aim. We hope that we can get there, it’s what we’re striving for.”
Some 70 miles away, in the neighboring county of Kent, another winegrower — Graham Barbour, founder and owner of the successful Woodchurch vineyard — is rather less enthusiastic about Sussex’s PDO award.
“It’s a shame that you’re singling out a county and saying the wine produced from that county is somehow unique and of superior quality because of the soil that it’s sitting on,” Barbour complained.
The fact is, he said, that a lot of vineyards in Kent also have chalky soil, whereas a lot of vineyards in Sussex do not. And the two counties have the same climate. He argued that it doesn’t make sense to define a wine region — and award a PDO — along county lines.
“Choosing a county is just arbitrary,” he said. “You can talk about a particular valley, a particular set of hills, but choosing a whole county is arbitrary. You can go to lots of other places in different counties around England and taste fantastic wines too.”
And you can go to some places in Sussex where the wine is not that good? “That would be the inference of what I’m saying, yes,” Barbour said.
Back in his Sussex vineyard, Art Tukker is still enthusing about the PDO, which he believes will bring the Sussex label to the attention of wine drinkers in Tokyo, New York and perhaps even Paris. He shrugs off the assertion from Kent that the PDO was awarded arbitrarily.
“The guys in Kent would say that, wouldn’t they?“ he laughed “Because they haven’t got their own PDO!”
And he served up the inevitable jibe: “Kent producers have probably got a case of sour grapes.”
But maybe the Kent winegrower has a point. Champagne, the ultimate PDO wine, encompasses parts of eight different counties — or departements — in France. It is not confined within the boundary of just one county.
There’s a lot happening in the world. Through it all, Marketplace is here for you.
You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible.
Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.