Wal-Mart not always an urban booster

Marketplace Staff Feb 18, 2010

Wal-Mart not always an urban booster

Marketplace Staff Feb 18, 2010


Steve Chiotakis: Retail giant Wal-Mart releases quarterly earnings in just a few hours. Analysts expect higher profits over a year ago, and part of that growth can be chalked up to Wal-Mart’s strategy of expanding into urban markets. Supporters say Wal-Mart provides urban economies a much-needed boost, but a new study questions that claim. From Chicago Public Radio, Adriene Hill reports.

Adriene Hill: Political headwinds against Wal-Mart have been fierce all over the country. In Chicago, Wal-Mart has only gotten a toehold in the city, where it has just one store on the west side.

It’s late afternoon. The parking lot is about three-quarters full. Will Wells is walking out with some lemonade, Hawaiian Punch and underwear.

Will Wells: Yeah it’s pretty good. It has a lot of things that I need, and like I said it’s not that far from my house.

Right down the street, Smokey Lee runs a shop that sells and installs audio equipment. He’s pretty happy with Wal-Mart, too.

Smokey Lee: People buy radio from there and come get installation from here.

Hill: So since it’s opened you think it’s been better?

Lee: Yeah, more people more traffic.

But economics professor David Merriman the University of Illinois at Chicago says the study he co-authored shows Walmart’s opening here has forced small businesses out. And:

David Merriman: The net effect is that the number of jobs that were lost by those businesses closing is pretty much a match by the number of jobs that Wal-Mart added when it opened its stores. So it was kind of pretty much a wash.

Merriman says that should change the debate for big cities that are thinking of letting Wal-Mart in.

Merriman: Instead of talking about jobs, whether this is, whether being for or against Wal-Mart is pro or anti-jobs, what we really should be talking about is what kind of neighborhoods do we want, what kind of development do we want.

For its part, Wal-Mart is contesting the validity of the study. It hired a third-party research firm to review Merriman’s findings. The report finds flaws with the original study.

Right or wrong, Morningstar analyst Joel Bloomer says research like Merriman’s might slow Wal-Mart’s move into big cities, but won’t stop it.

Joel Bloomer: I think in the end, their kind of low-price offering will win out. So it happens eventually, it’s just it takes longer.

Bloomer guesses it’s just a matter of time before Wal-Mart shopping bags are as ubiquitous in cities as they are everywhere else.

In Chicago, I’m Adriene Hill for Marketplace.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.