5

Battle lines being drawn in fight against online piracy

A hacker works on a computer with a skull on it, which symbolizes online crime and Internet theft.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Leahy introduced the Combating Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act last year. It sailed out of committee on a unanimous vote but was derailed by Senator Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), who lined up with groups including the ACLU and the Electronic Frontier Foundation, which criticized the bill as being an ineffective and unfair measure.

Indications are that Leahy is gearing up to introduce a new version of the bill very soon. There are reports that his office has been quietly lobbying Google and various Internet service providers for their support. Verizon will reportedly be present at today's hearings; Google will not.

We speak to Senator Leahy in today's show. He says trafficking in unlicensed material on the Internet is no different than dealing in stolen goods out of a warehouse somewhere; a crime is a crime. Leahy says that he can see a scenario where the operators of a site have the right to appeal a shutdown, after the shutdown occurs. As for what would constitute reasonable cause for shutting it down, he hopes to talk about that at the hearing.

We also talk to David Sohn, senior policy counsel at the Center for Democracy and Technology. He says that going after criminals is important but that the focus should be on the people and not the websites. The line between what part of a site is free speech and what's illegal business is too hard to separate, he says.

Also in this program, a talk with actor and Internet bon vivant Wil Wheaton.

About the author

John Moe is the host of Marketplace Tech Report, where he provides an insightful overview of the latest tech news.
Lars Severson's picture
Lars Severson - Feb 24, 2011

I remember the days when people thought that nothing would come of this online world we now live within. Unfortunately with the good also comes the bad and those that would want to take advantage of other's rather than carving out a life of their own.

Lars Severson
http://blog.PrintPlace.com

TheGenie IsOutOfTheBottle's picture
TheGenie IsOutO... - Feb 16, 2011

With the invention of the mp3, the genie was let out of the bottle. The only way to put the genie back is to price content such that piracy is not worth the effort. Maybe recording artists and actors will only get paid what wall street gets paid!

Jordan Ledbetter's picture
Jordan Ledbetter - Feb 16, 2011

The RIAA is doomed. Technology giveth, and technology taketh away. Music was part of human culture before Edison, and it will not die with Bill Gates. Vendors of music will suffer, but musicians will always be compensated for their work. Micro lending sites are already connecting fans directly to the artists, giving free artistic licence to the musicians. Connections like these are the future of music; prosecuting minors for copyright infringement will only further alienate those at the RIAA from the real consumers of music.

Nick Samuels's picture
Nick Samuels - Feb 16, 2011

Colleen give me a break. Do you have a job? Would you like to work and then have someone tell you that they will enjoy the fruits of your labor without compensating you? Internet piracy is the exact same thing.

Colleen Burke's picture
Colleen Burke - Feb 16, 2011

Screw Leahy! How many millions did the RIAA give you Leahy, you stooge! These websites serve not only a convenient purpose, but a political purpose to bring down the evil RIAA!