After months of controversy over virus outbreaks, Chipotle looks to reward loyal customers. 
After months of controversy over virus outbreaks, Chipotle looks to reward loyal customers.  - 
Listen To The Story

Chipotle is starting a new customer loyalty program on Friday, running through summer, in its effort to recover business after food-poisoning outbreaks that sickened hundreds of people. Revenue was down more than 20 percent in the first quarter this year, compared with a year ago, and restaurant sales were down almost 30 percent.

One recovery strategy? The Chiptopia card. Doesn’t exactly roll off the tongue, but Chipotle is hoping this new loyalty rewards program gets more customers rolling into its stores. In general, these programs are very effective, Kelly Weikel, director of consumer insights at Technomic, said. 

“We keep seeing new brands entering the space and other brands continually updating what they’re offering to keep pace and improve the value proposition for customers,” she said. 

At least 40 percent of consumers expect restaurants to have some sort of loyalty program, according to Weikel. So the best ones break through the noise. 

“I think that differentiation is really important as these become more and more common,” she said. 

Lars Perner, who teaches marketing at the Marshall School of Business at USC, said Chipotle should be careful not to seem like it’s trying too hard.

“Say a free meal every third time, or something like that,” Perner said, “that comes across as too much.” 

Chipotle is requiring four visits a month to get a free meal. Eat there more often, and you get bigger rewards. Perner says research shows people can see through overly generous rewards, and they feel  manipulated.

Wagner dos Santos, vice president of strategy and insights at the Orlando marketing firm Bigeye, said it takes a lot of work to regain trust. And for Chipotle, he said, a loyalty rewards program “may be a little premature.” 

He said the company might work on rebuilding loyalty before it expects loyalty in return. 

Sign up to stay connected to Marketplace and you could be in for a Halloween treat!

Subscribe to our daily newsletter by Oct. 31 and you're automatically entered to win one of 10 Marketplace treat bags. They're filled with some great swag, plus something unique to give you a peek behind the scenes — a program rundown signed by Kai Ryssdal.

Subscribe today for your chance to win – and good luck!