Streaming rescued record labels. But has it abandoned artists?

Jasmine Garsd Feb 7, 2020
Share Now on:
HTML EMBED:
COPY
Metallica sued Napster over piracy concerns, during an era music analysts refer to as a dark moment for the record industry. Kevin Winter/Getty

Streaming rescued record labels. But has it abandoned artists?

Jasmine Garsd Feb 7, 2020
Metallica sued Napster over piracy concerns, during an era music analysts refer to as a dark moment for the record industry. Kevin Winter/Getty
Share Now on:
HTML EMBED:
COPY

Warner Music Group is going public again.

When Warner Music went private in 2011, the music industry had been in a downward spiral for years. CD sales were tanking. Piracy was rampant.

“It was an abject wasteland for the recorded music industry,” said George Howard, who teaches business at the Berklee College Of Music and used to work at Sony. “It was a really dark time. “ 

Piracy drove the band Metallica to sue Napster, a platform that let people share music without paying for it, in 2000. But the real change came from music streaming services in 2014 or so.

“Streaming services absolutely saved the music industry,” said music analyst Bob Lefsetz. “It certainly started with Spotify.”

Streaming now accounts for about 75% of the industry’s revenue.

“One way to think about this is water,” said Carnegie Mellon professor Michael Smith. “We have water fountains everywhere. And yet people will cheerfully pay a couple bucks for a bottle of water because it’s convenient and I can carry it around. I think exactly the same thing happened with Spotify.”

And the money is starting to pour back in for record labels. Warner Music had revenue of $1.26 billion last quarter, its best in about 15 years.

But the question of whether music streaming is good for artists remains been contentious.

“Streaming is great, except for the parts that are bad,” Smith joked. “And the parts that are bad are, all of a sudden, music is everywhere. So I think that’s lowered the amount of money artists are getting paid.”

“Musicians still aren’t getting a fair shake,” musician and columnist Kabir Sehgal wrote in a 2018. “Here’s the math: Spotify pays about $0.006 to $0.0084 per stream to the holder of music rights. And the ‘holder’ can be split among the record label, producers, artists, and songwriters.”

Drexel University music professor Marc Offenbach says streaming also hurt independent record labels who represent less mainstream artists.

“All these independent record labels who used to sell 10,000 [to] 20,000 copies of CDs per release,” he said. “That was a business model, and it was a nice piece of revenue. They’re all getting hurt.”

Not everyone agrees. Lesfetz, the music analyst, says the most successful artists are making more money now than they used to, adjusted for inflation. And they’re less reliant on labels to reach that level of success. The goal of most artist used to be getting signed by a label, which would pump money into marketing musicians in order to make them stars.

“Whereas today, they want you to prove success on your own,” Lesfetz said, “via SoundCloud, Spotify, YouTube.”

If you’re a member of your local public radio station, we thank you — because your support helps those stations keep programs like Marketplace on the air.  But for Marketplace to continue to grow, we need additional investment from those who care most about what we do: superfans like you.

Your donation — as little as $5 — helps us create more content that matters to you and your community, and to reach more people where they are – whether that’s radio, podcasts or online.

When you contribute directly to Marketplace, you become a partner in that mission: someone who understands that when we all get smarter, everybody wins.

We’re here for you.

As COVID-19 reshapes our economy, our newsletter will help you unpack the news from the day.