Help us end the fiscal year strong. Donate by June 30. Give Now
COVID-19

How Shanghai’s DIY supply chains helped us live through the long COVID lockdown

Jennifer Pak Jun 6, 2022
Heard on:
HTML EMBED:
COPY
A volunteer clad in safety gear delivers food during the lockdown while Shanghai residents were not allowed to leave their apartments. Charles Zhang/Marketplace
COVID-19

How Shanghai’s DIY supply chains helped us live through the long COVID lockdown

Jennifer Pak Jun 6, 2022
Heard on:
A volunteer clad in safety gear delivers food during the lockdown while Shanghai residents were not allowed to leave their apartments. Charles Zhang/Marketplace
HTML EMBED:
COPY

I received my first proper food delivery during lockdown a month after being sealed in my home.

For a moment, the barbecue ribs, burger and fries gave me and my boyfriend a feeling of normalcy.

Before these strict anti-COVID measures, food delivery was a staple in my life. If I forgot onions for the pasta one night or had a craving for bubble tea, I could get those items delivered within 30 minutes for less than $2. But on April 1, Shanghai went into citywide confinement, and the supply chain collapsed.

“During the lockdown, all these delivery people are not allowed to leave their home,” Long Wong of ProA Supply Chain in Shanghai said.

The city is easing some restrictions, but for more than 60 days, most residents were stuck at home. Ordering basic things, such as food and groceries, was difficult, and the task of getting fed fell on district governments, neighbors and friends.

The fourth government handout Zhang received on day 20 of the lockdown, while Pak's apartment complex was already on its seventh handout. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
The fourth government handout Charles Zhang received, which came on Day 20 of the lockdown. By then, Jennifer Pak’s apartment complex was on its seventh handout. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

Shanghai’s government sealed the city’s border. While Shanghai is a transport hub, many of its retail warehouses are located just outside the city, where land is cheaper, according to Wong.

Businesses were also closed down and forced to apply to reopen.

“The attitude from the central government is that you have to be strict. So, they [were] only letting the most essential, for example, medical supply, to go through,” Wong said.

Jennifer Pak’s first proper food delivery since the citywide lockdown began.

Food apps channel

Suddenly, over 10 million households had to wake up at the crack of dawn to fight for the limited delivery spots from the few drivers who were still able to move about. The household of Marketplace news assistant Charles Zhang was cycling through at least five food apps.

The process is so complex that my friends circulated an Excel spreadsheet on what time different apps start taking orders. I got one delivery slot, but by the time I checked out, the only thing left in my virtual cart was a case of Tsingtao beer.

Retail revolution

The sudden food shortage was jarring given how convenient delivery usually is in Shanghai. Part of the advantage stems from the fact that China’s economy opened to the outside world only in the late 1970s.

“Unlike the U.S., [where] we have a lot of big-box retailers for the last maybe 100 years, in China the big-box retailers didn’t really establish their presence until the 2000s, and [this] time frame coincided with the e-commerce revolution,” Wong said.

The investment in e-commerce has meant that same-day delivery was built into retailers’ plans early on, he added. When Amazon was pushing out in-home delivery in 2017, I was living in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen, and I had already been receiving packages in a third-party locker service in front of our apartment building when we weren’t home. The delivery driver would text me the locker code to retrieve the package.

Food delivery truck in Shanghai was a rare sight in the initial days of the lockdown after the city government sealed the border so tight no trucks could enter or leave. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
A food delivery truck in Shanghai was a rare sight in the initial days of the lockdown. The city government sealed the border so tight that no trucks could enter or leave. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

“Unlike the U.S., which is very spread out, China [has] a few mega cities or [is] city-centric,” Wong said. “Every city is like a New York City to the China landscape … so you have a lot more forward distribution centers and shorter fulfillment time.”

Grocery delivery has followed the same route. “Grocery providers are building small warehouses close to population centers [that] can deliver in 29 minutes, like Dingdong … to supermarkets serving as [both] a warehouse and a retail spot. And they deliver out to the surrounding” area, Wong said.

He said the final piece to complete the last-mile delivery is China’s army of drivers on electric bicycles, who typically hail from poorer provinces.

Zhang documented his buying adventures.

Bulk buying channel

Without the usual fleet of delivery drivers, I have been lucky to have capable neighbors who organized bulk buys. But the food is often pricier than usual, and I must buy 60 eggs, 14 pounds of vegetables or a case of avocados in one go.

There are also box sets of mixed groceries from grocers. I once paid $70 for one, and all I wanted was the eggs and meat. These are not great options for consumers, but it simplifies things for suppliers.

“By everybody eating the same thing, you save a lot of manual labor in terms of picking and sorting and packaging, right? So instead of you getting ABC and he gets XYZ, everybody gets DEF,” Wong said.

I also had friends and underground channels to source soy sauce, instant noodles and even luxury items like ice cream bars. 

Zhang's neighbor bought a whole hog and sold to people in his apartment complex. Some neighbors have become very skilled at sourcing for food during this lockdown. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Zhang’s neighbor bought a whole hog and sold it in parts to people in his apartment complex. Some neighbors have become very skilled at sourcing food during the lockdown. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

District government channel

My district government also provided handouts. One week, we would receive food like a carrot, three potatoes, some bok choy and two chunks of fatty pork. The handouts were helpful, but we were never sure when the next one would arrive.

Delivery drivers resting in between orders in Shanghai. These workers often have to live on the streets to avoid lockdown measures at their apartment complexes. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Delivery drivers rest between orders in Shanghai. These workers often have to live on the streets to avoid lockdown measures at their apartment complexes. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

Another week, we’d receive bean curd sticks, fermented bean curd and gluten — stuff I’ve not cooked with before. But we were lucky. Some districts, like Zhang’s, had received only half the amount of goods.

Videos of fed-up residents show them banging pots and pans to demand more food, while others protested the endless lockdown.

People flooded public hotlines with complaints. A man’s call with his district government went viral.

“Up until now, medics can’t save lives, children can’t go to school, workers can’t work, and we tolerated it all. Chinese people are very peaceful. But once you touch on our ability to eat and survive, that is crossing a line,” the man said.

Perhaps the hardest hit are delivery drivers. “After they leave their home, they cannot go back. [We’ve] seen reports that people live under the bridge. They are subject to daily [COVID] testing. They have a tough time finding things to eat, even though they are delivering food to people,” Wong said.

Volunteers helping to deliver handouts from a Shanghai district government. The handouts have been uneven across the financial capital where the wealthiest areas appear to have received better supplies and more than districts that are in need. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Volunteers help deliver handouts from a Shanghai district government. The provisions have been unevenly distributed across the financial capital, where the wealthiest areas appear to have received better and more supplies than needy districts. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

Shanghai is phasing out restrictions, but that could change if there are new COVID cases.

“A lot of companies, all [of a] sudden, are interested in having regional warehouses [and] to have multiple supply chain route,” Wong said.

If there’s a snap lockdown again, Zhang said, his place has 80 pounds of flour and 4 gallons of cooking oil.

As for me, I’ve got nine jugs of vinegar, 33 pounds of rice and 12 boxes of cereal.

Additional research by Charles Zhang.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.