Find the latest episode of "This Is Uncomfortable" here. Listen

Pandemic pushes big-city dreamers out of Shanghai

Jennifer Pak Mar 30, 2021
Heard on:
HTML EMBED:
COPY
Parents boast about their unmarried children's achievements on handwritten notes taped to umbrellas at Shanghai's People's Park. The ads bring China's urban-rural divide into sharp focus. Charles Zhang/Marketplace

Pandemic pushes big-city dreamers out of Shanghai

Jennifer Pak Mar 30, 2021
Heard on:
Parents boast about their unmarried children's achievements on handwritten notes taped to umbrellas at Shanghai's People's Park. The ads bring China's urban-rural divide into sharp focus. Charles Zhang/Marketplace
HTML EMBED:
COPY

On a Saturday in January 2020, real estate agent Eric He strolled through Shanghai’s People’s Park.

The park on weekends transforms into a so-called marriage market. Well-intentioned parents advertise their unmarried children’s qualities on handwritten notes tacked on to umbrellas.

Mr. He, a bachelor who is under pressure from his parents to get married, should be able to boast that he is the first in his family to graduate from college and can save money regularly.

Yet, he is treated as a second-class citizen mainly because his household registration, or his “hukou,” is in the Chinese countryside and not in Shanghai. This limits his ability to buy a home, get any future children into schools or retire in the city.

“For anyone not from the city, we are seen as village people in the eyes of the Shanghainese,” Mr. He said.

For decades, hundreds of millions of people like Mr. He from the rural countryside head to cities like Shanghai for a better life. The most recent official statistics, from 2019, show that 40% of Shanghai’s population of 24.3 million do not have household registrations in the financial center.

The COVID-19 pandemic has pushed some of them out before they could realize their big-city dream, which was no easy feat even before the coronavirus outbreak.

Eric He in Shanghai's marriage market prior to the pandemic lockdown last year. He dreamed of settling in Shanghai one day. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Eric He in Shanghai’s marriage market prior to the pandemic lockdown last year. He dreamed of settling in Shanghai one day. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

The lack of a Shanghai household registration was a deal breaker for one mother standing near Mr. He at the People’s Park marriage market.

“If he isn’t registered to Shanghai, that won’t work. My daughter has an apartment, she has a Shanghai hukou, has a good job and a good education,” she said. “I want a son-in-law with the same background as her.”

That may sound harsh, but Mr. He understood her point. He and a Shanghai girlfriend broke up over the same issue.

“Her household registration was in Shanghai, [and obtaining] this identity is an insurmountable barrier [for me],” Mr. He said.

Still, he was initially drawn to China’s financial center because of the opportunities available.

Shortly after he joined the real estate firm in Shanghai, a colleague earned 500,000 yuan ($77,000) in commissions in one month.

“I’m now in my late 20s. I’ve got less than 30 years to go before retirement, which isn’t a long time,” Mr. He said. “If I have one or two big opportunities like that, I can change my life.”

Zou Chaogang sings karaoke in Shanghai to relieve stress. Prior to the pandemic he struggled to pay rent and buy food. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Zou Chaogang sings karaoke in Shanghai to relieve stress. Prior to the pandemic, he struggled to pay rent and buy food. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

People without college degrees have far fewer opportunities.

The Zou family hails from eastern Jiangxi province but worked in Shanghai for years. However, low salaries and the lack of Shanghai registration eventually drove the family out.

The son, Zou Chaogang, returned to the city as an adult and ended up in a factory that paid him less than $9,000 a year taking photos to authenticate Nike and Adidas shoes.

“I did the same task every day, and it got boring after a while,” Zou said.

He quit his factory job after three months, just before the pandemic lockdown.

“I feel lost. I don’t know what to do in Shanghai. When I look for a job, I need it to provide free room and board. Otherwise rent will take up half a month’s salary. Food is expensive as well,” he said. “It’s just so hard to survive here.”

Parents at Shanghai's People's Park last year surveyed marriage adverts, which openly discloses salary and assets. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Last year, parents at People’s Park in Shanghai surveyed marriage advertisements, which openly disclose salary and assets. (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Marriage ad: "Shanghai female; born March '89; bachelors degree; height: 5'3; good-looking, virtuous and considerate; Shanghai hospital lab technician; seeking: Shanghai male with property; no bad habits; considerate; responsible; healthy." (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
A marriage ad reads: “Shanghai female; born March ’89; bachelors degree; height: 5’3; good-looking, virtuous and considerate; Shanghai hospital lab technician; seeking: Shanghai male with property; no bad habits; considerate; responsible; healthy.” (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Marriage ad: "Only child; female; born '85; never been married; height: 5'3; good looking; has property and hukou in Shanghai; Masters' degree in Hong Kong;  parents with pension; doing legal work; salary: abundant. Seeking: male; age 40 and younger; top university graduate; bachelors' degree or higher; motivated; good looking; stable job with a matching background (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)
Another marriage ad: “Only child; female; born ’85; never been married; height: 5’3; good looking; has property and hukou in Shanghai; Masters’ degree in Hong Kong; parents with pension; doing legal work; salary: abundant. Seeking: male; age 40 and younger; top university graduate; bachelors’ degree or higher; motivated; good looking; stable job with a matching background.” (Charles Zhang/Marketplace)

In late January 2020, Zou and Mr. He were outside of Shanghai spending time with their families for the Lunar New Year when China went into a lockdown.

They could not return for months.

During this time, Mr. He’s parents also returned to their hometown from southern Guangdong province. After working there for nearly two decades, they also couldn’t settle there. They started up their own business in their native central Hubei province.

Eric He found a job closer to his hometown after the pandemic, with a higher salary and better benefits than his Shanghai job. (Courtesy of Eric He)
Eric He found a job closer to his hometown after the pandemic, with a higher salary and better benefits than his Shanghai job. (Courtesy of Eric He)

Mr. He, who was not paid by his Shanghai company during the lockdown, started to rethink his big-city dream.

“Shanghai is such a stressful city, and I’ve always wanted to be closer to my parents,” he said.

Eric He bought an apartment near his hometown in central Hubei province with his new job. (Courtesy of Eric He)
Eric He bought an apartment near his hometown in central Hubei province after getting a new job. (Courtesy of Eric He)

Mr. He found another real estate job near his village, where the cost of living is lower. With the help of his parents, he even bought an apartment.

“My salary is higher than in Shanghai. The company pays into my social security and my housing fund, which I didn’t get in my Shanghai job,” Mr. He said. “I also get perks like a cake for my birthday.”

Mr. He said he still works six days a week and even longer hours, but he is content. He is now in his hometown, and with property. But he does not regret trying to make it in Shanghai, he said.

As for ex-factory worker Zou, he hasn’t returned to Shanghai since the lockdown lifted in April.

Before Zou left the city, he and a friend stopped in a karaoke booth at a mall. He said he sings to relieve stress.

They chose a song about sticking with your dreams called “Boundless Oceans, Vast Skies” from the ’80s Cantonese rock band Beyond.

The chorus goes: “Forgive me for loving freedom in life/ Though I’m afraid of falling one day/ Anyone can abandon his or her ideals/ I won’t fear, even if one day it’s just you and me left.”

Zou’s dream is to make enough to pay off his credit cards and gambling debts.

He is still trying to make it in other cities.

Additional research by Charles Zhang.

Marketplace is on a mission.

We believe Main Street matters as much as Wall Street, economic news is made relevant and real through human stories, and a touch of humor helps enliven topics you might typically find…well, dull.

Through the signature style that only Marketplace can deliver, we’re on a mission to raise the economic intelligence of the country—but we don’t do it alone. We count on listeners and readers like you to keep this public service free and accessible to all. Will you become a partner in our mission today?

Your donation is critical to the future of public service journalism. Support our work today – for as little as $5 – and help us keep making people smarter.