Tell us about your experiences with Marketplace. Enter To Win
COVID-19

Kudlow says extra $600 for unemployment benefits will end in July

David Brancaccio, Nova Safo, and Alex Schroeder Jun 15, 2020
Heard on:
HTML EMBED:
COPY
Kudlow says the Trump administration is looking at a potential bonus for people returning to work. Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images
COVID-19

Kudlow says extra $600 for unemployment benefits will end in July

David Brancaccio, Nova Safo, and Alex Schroeder Jun 15, 2020
Heard on:
Kudlow says the Trump administration is looking at a potential bonus for people returning to work. Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images
HTML EMBED:
COPY

The Federal government has been supplementing state unemployment benefits during the pandemic by $600 a week at a time more than 20 million people are jobless.

Congress is now debating whether to extend the benefit, but the White House is worried it makes not working too attractive. White House economic adviser Larry Kudlow said Sunday on CNN the additional money is disincentivizing some workers from returning to their jobs.

Marketplace’s Nova Safo has the details. The following is an edited transcript of his conversation with “Marketplace Morning Report” host David Brancaccio.

David Brancaccio: What did Kudlow, the director of the United States National Economic Council, say this weekend?

Nova Safo: He said the Trump administration is considering whether to provide a bonus payment to people who go back to work. Congress is debating right now about whether to extend the $600 a week benefit. Democrats want to keep providing the money until January. But here’s what Kudlow said on CNN yesterday:

“We’re paying people not to work, it’s better than their salaries would get. And, that might have worked for the first couple of months. It’ll end in late July. We are — in the administration, the president — looking at a reform measure that will still provide some kind of bonus for returning to work.”

Brancaccio: Is this a supposition, or is there evidence people are blowing off jobs because of the extra unemployment money?

Safo: It’s anecdotal. Kudlow says he’s heard from business leaders who’re saying they’re seeing this phenomenon play out.

The Congressional Budget Office did look at the question. It’s previously said that low-wage workers have borne the brunt of job losses.

And looking at how extending the $600 benefit would impact workers, the CBO projected that, yes, fewer people will return to work, because they’ll be making more money if they stay home, at least in the short-term. But, it also concluded that extending the benefits would boost demand for goods and services, which in turn would help the economy.


We reached out to several labor economists for responses to Kudlow’s comments.

Here’s what they had to say:

Gary Burtless, senior fellow, economic studies at The Brookings Institution: “I think it is very likely that the generous $600-per-week top-up does indeed ‘disincentivize’ laid-off workers’ search for another job. Remember, though, this is partly by design, because lawmakers wanted to allow workers to remain safely at home, reducing the likelihood they would become infected by the COVID-19 coronavirus.

“Even though the very generous UI payment is reducing laid-off workers’ job search efforts and their willingness to accept (possibly unsafe) job offers, it is not clear whether this is actually reducing the number of job openings that employers can fill. In mid-May the unemployment rate was 13.3% (and possibly higher depending on how we count people who said they were employed but who were absent from their jobs). According to the BLS household survey, there were 21 million jobless workers who were trying to find jobs. There is absolutely no evidence that many of these unemployed could have found jobs, even if they were willing to spend 40 or 50 hours every week searching industriously for their next jobs.”

Indi Dutta-Gupta, co-executive director of the Georgetown Law Center on Poverty & Inequality: “If we want more people to return to work, we need to control this virus, ensure that people are safe at work, and guarantee child care and elder care. The $600 weekly unemployment benefit did not prevent more than 2 million people from returning to work last month. With a hole of roughly 20 million jobs, if anything, supercharged unemployment benefits prevent employers from receiving hundreds of desperate applicants for each opening — something that is an enormous waste of their and workers’ time and energy.”

Doug Holmes, president, UWC-Strategic Services on Unemployment and Workers’ Compensation: “There were studies that reviewed the 2008-2009 recession. One by the National Bureau of Economic Research and an update by AEI that showed that one impact is that fewer jobs are created.

“The CBO has recognized for decades that an extension of benefits results in an increase in unemployment duration. This is widely recognized by economists as a fundamental proposition. The amount of extended duration is impacted by a variety of factors.”

Bill Rodgers, chief economist, Heldrich Center for Workforce Development at Rutgers: “There is economic literature that shows when non-labor income (in this case UI Benefits) go up, the likelihood of searching for work goes down. The research also shows that when the support is about to go away and goes away, odds of searching for a job go up.

“Problem here is first the closing of the economy, such that there were no jobs to go to. Now there is the uncertainty of workplace safety, consumption that is slowly restoring itself, plus jobs that may never come back.

“It is hard to search for a job when the number is limited and the quality of those jobs has some uncertainty to them.”

COVID-19 Economy FAQs

What do I need to know about tax season this year?

Glad you asked! We have a whole separate FAQ section on that. Some quick hits: The deadline has been extended from April 15 to May 17 for individuals. Also, millions of people received unemployment benefits in 2020 — up to $10,200 of which will now be tax-free for those with an adjusted gross income of less than $150,000. And, for those who filed before the American Rescue Plan passed, simply put, you do not need to file an amended return at the moment. Find answers to the rest of your questions here.

How long will it be until the economy is back to normal?

It feels like things are getting better, more and more people getting vaccinated, more businesses opening, but we’re not entirely out of the woods. To illustrate: two recent pieces of news from the Centers for Disease Control. Item 1: The CDC is extending its tenant eviction moratorium to June 30. Item 2: The cruise industry didn’t get what it wanted — restrictions on sailing from U.S. ports will stay in place until November. Very different issues with different stakes, but both point to the fact that the CDC thinks we still have a ways to go before the pandemic is over, according to Dr. Philip Landrigan, who used to work at the CDC and now teaches at Boston College.

How are those COVID relief payments affecting consumers?

Payments started going out within days of President Joe Biden signing the American Rescue Plan, and that’s been a big shot in the arm for consumers, said John Leer at Morning Consult, which polls Americans every day. “Consumer confidence is really on a tear. They are growing more confident at a faster rate than they have following the prior two stimulus packages.” Leer said this time around the checks are bigger and they’re getting out faster. Now, rising confidence is likely to spark more consumer spending. But Lisa Rowan at Forbes Advisor said it’s not clear how much or how fast.

Read More

Collapse

Marketplace is on a mission.

We believe Main Street matters as much as Wall Street, economic news is made relevant and real through human stories, and a touch of humor helps enliven topics you might typically find…well, dull.

Through the signature style that only Marketplace can deliver, we’re on a mission to raise the economic intelligence of the country—but we don’t do it alone. We count on listeners and readers like you to keep this public service free and accessible to all. Will you become a partner in our mission today?

Your donation is critical to the future of public service journalism. Support our work today – for as little as $5 – and help us keep making people smarter.