There’s a mysterious lack of inflation in the U.S. economy — especially since unemployment is at a 50-year low.
The Consumer Price Index rose 2.1% in November — mostly thanks to energy and housing costs. The inflation measure that the Federal Reserve prefers to use — Personal Consumption Expenditures — rose by only 1.3% in October.
What gives? Fed Chairman Jay Powell gave one possible explanation during his press conference Wednesday. Marketplace’s Nancy Marshall-Genzer asked why wages aren’t growing as much as we might expect.
“The idea that you can make, manufacture, or even provide services anywhere in the world to anywhere in the world, I think that hangs over the wage-setting process,” Powell replied. “There isn’t the kind of traction in the wage market, even in a tight labor market.”
An ever-changing labor market
In other words, American workers are now competing with workers all over the world. The labor market and business supply chains are global, leading to lower prices.
“Institutional changes in the labor market have really undercut workers’ ability to bargain for higher wages — things like decline of unions and globalization,” said Jesse Rothstein, a labor economist at UC Berkeley.
Global supply chains allow importers to find the cheapest suppliers of lawn chairs or laptops, and the cheapest workers to make them, according to economist Mark Kuperberg at Swarthmore College.
“The possibility of offshoring is a huge disincentive to labor to ask for higher wages,” Kuperberg said.
Kate Bronfenbrenner, director of labor education research at Cornell University, said global outsourcing has scared workers, starting a few decades back in manufacturing.
“We now have outsourcing just as high, if not higher, in the service sector and in white-collar jobs,” Bronfenbrenner said. “There’s the feeling that almost any job can be outsourced.”
With the internet, companies can easily find firms or freelancers offering web development, marketing, accounting and legal services.
“The primary way that U.S. businesses have responded to this is to hire remote workers within the U.S. and not to offshore those jobs,” said Adam Ozimek, chief economist at gig work website Upwork.
That means tech gig workers in San Francisco might make a little less, while their competitors in St. Louis make a little more.
Availability of products and services
This same global trend applies to consumers — both individuals and businesses buying products and services.
“The ease of searching through places like Amazon does lower the variation and the prices,” said Max Gillman, a professor of economic history at the University of Missouri-St Louis. “That can lead to a lower measured aggregate inflation rate.”
Internet-comparison shopping has kept prices down, but maybe not as much as we think. Alan Detmeister, an economist with UBS, said there has been price competition for 100 years.
Over the decades, we’ve gone from mom-and-pop stores, to specialty stores, to big box stores. Best Buy and Walmart were once revolutionary like Amazon is today. But we didn’t have the inflation lull we do today. It’s very easy to overstate the impact of the internet on holding down prices,” Detmeister said.
If online shopping had singlehandedly put the lid on inflation, we would have seen inflation pause for things you can shop online for, but rise for things you can’t — services like transportation. The gap between inflation in goods and services would expand, but we’re not seeing that.
Comparison shopping with the internet is holding down some prices, but not all. Sure, there are bargains for discount shoppers but sometimes there are higher prices for people who don’t know any better.
“Firms are figuring out how they can charge different prices to different buyers for the same thing,” said Joe Gagnon, an economist with the Peterson Institute. “Some are going down and some are going up.”
This leaves us with a persistent inflation mystery in economics on our hands. For now, maybe just be happy prices aren’t spiking.
Marketplace is on a mission.
We believe Main Street matters as much as Wall Street, economic news is made relevant and real through human stories, and a touch of humor helps enliven topics you might typically find…well, dull.
Through the signature style that only Marketplace can deliver, we’re on a mission to raise the economic intelligence of the country—but we don’t do it alone. We count on listeners and readers like you to keep this public service free and accessible to all. Will you become a partner in our mission today?