Marketplace®
Every story is an economic story

That skincare you bought online? It could be counterfeit

Rose Maura Lorre of Wirecutter bought and tested a dozen products from third-party sellers on major e-retailers. Every single one raised red flags.

Download
Based on her experiment, Lorre said the best ways to shop for beauty products are via a brand's official website or at brick and mortar retailers like Sephora or Target.
Based on her experiment, Lorre said the best ways to shop for beauty products are via a brand's official website or at brick and mortar retailers like Sephora or Target.
Carolyn Van Houten/The Washington Post via Getty Images

Rose Maura Lorre, a senior staff writer at Wirecutter, hired a cosmetic chemist to test 12 beauty products she bought from third-party retailers online. To compare, she also bought the same products directly from the brands’ own websites.

Lorre spoke with “Marketplace” host Kristin Schwab about her experiment, starting with a lip treatment from the brand Rhode.

“This chemist noticed the one that I’d purchased third party was sort of puffier, bloatier,” Lorre said. “So she was like, this could be indicative of bacteria growing inside the package.”

Lorre said the product testing changed the way she’ll shop going forward, and that “I cannot tell anyone in good conscience, shop third party, certainly not for anything you’re putting in or on your body.”

Click the audio player above to hear the conversation.

Related Topics

Collections:

Latest Episodes

View All Shows
  • Marketplace
    an hour ago
    25:22
  • Marketplace Morning Report
    9 hours ago
    7:09
  • Million Bazillion
    14 hours ago
    30:57
  • Marketplace Tech
    14 hours ago
    12:45
  • This Is Uncomfortable
    6 days ago
    28:44
  • Make Me Smart
    4 months ago
    24:33