Find the latest episode of "This Is Uncomfortable" here. Listen

Tariff pain: Will the U.S. or China hurt the most?

Jennifer Pak Aug 27, 2018
Li Dapeng says her consumption of American brands and imported products is modest compared to her four-year-old son. Jennifer Pak/Marketplace

Tariff pain: Will the U.S. or China hurt the most?

Jennifer Pak Aug 27, 2018
Li Dapeng says her consumption of American brands and imported products is modest compared to her four-year-old son. Jennifer Pak/Marketplace

Li Dapeng and her husband Ye Yu live on the outskirts of Shanghai. Their two-bedroom apartment is cluttered with stuff.

Li, 37, fills her night stand with only imported cosmetics and skincare from Japan, France and the U.S. 

Together with her husband, Ye, she owns a Microsoft laptop, two Apple computers and an iPad. They also have two iPhones, which each cost about an average month’s wage in Shanghai.

However, Li said her consumption of American goods is modest compared to that of her four-year-old son.

Li buys her child National Geographic Kids magazines, Carter’s clothing, GNC multivitamins, Disney toys, Transformers and Crayola finger paint.

“The (Crayola) package says it’s OK if kids get the paint in their mouths. Chinese brands may make the same claim but I’m not sure,” Li said.

A string of food and medical scandals in China has driven up demand for imported products. The U.S. exported $130 billion worth of goods to China last year, while Americans bought $505 billion worth of Chinese goods.

A series of food scandals in China have led anxious parents to turn to imported products for their kids.

President Donald Trump believes the U.S. could be selling much more to China if the Chinese government didn’t put up so many barriers for foreign businesses. His tariffs on $34 billion worth of Chinese products are, in part, meant to force China to open its markets.

Chinese state media commentaries suggest that people in China will be able to weather the trade tariffs for the sake of national pride.

“[T]he trade war with America is a fight for China’s destiny. Its people and government are willing to make sacrifices, overcome difficulties, and make a concerted effort to safeguard the country’s sustainable economic development,” the state-run broadcast China Media Group said in a commentary days after the tariffs on $34 billion Chinese imports came into effect.

China has retaliated with tariffs targeting American farmers, who exported $20 billion worth of U.S. agricultural products to China last year while Chinese producers only exported $7 billion to the U.S.

Now American wine, fruits, vegetables and nuts entering China face a 15 percent tariff, while a 25 percent tariff is imposed on U.S. whiskey, meat and seafood.

“I buy American oranges and cashews but not frequently, so I haven’t noticed if prices have gone up yet,” Li said.

“My living standard has improved a lot, so I am not that sensitive to a price increase of 10 or 20 percent anyway,” Li said.

Li Dapeng (left) and husband Ye Yu with their son in Macau.

However, if the tariffs make products too expensive, Li has many choices of other types of imported foods.

Her fridge is stocked with French butter, Italian pasta sauce, South Korean milk and durian fruit from Thailand.

It is a big change from her childhood. Li said back then foreign goods were such a novelty that her parents would point out any foreign products they had to house guests.

“At that time, only our TV and video cassette recorder were imported. They were from Japan,” Li said.

Since then, Li and her family have benefited from 40-years of China’s “Reform and Opening” policy that opened the state-run economy to the outside world.

China’s government is now focused on raising the country’s high-tech manufacturing, which has alarmed President Trump, European leaders and businesses alike.

Like many Chinese citizens who have spoken to Marketplace, Li’s husband Ye believes this trade dispute is about stemming China’s rise.

If the current dispute escalates into a trade war, Ye thinks it will hurt the U.S. more than China.

“I am certain I can live without American products because they are not essential items,” he said.

Many U.S. exports are pricier things like American beef, cherries and children’s clothing.

However, even if Chinese consumers do not buy American, costs may still go up.

The pork in Ye’s fridge is from China, but to produce that meat, the pigs are fed on American soybeans, on which the Chinese government has now imposed a 25 percent tariff.

Marketplace is on a mission.

We believe Main Street matters as much as Wall Street, economic news is made relevant and real through human stories, and a touch of humor helps enliven topics you might typically find…well, dull.

Through the signature style that only Marketplace can deliver, we’re on a mission to raise the economic intelligence of the country—but we don’t do it alone. We count on listeners and readers like you to keep this public service free and accessible to all. Will you become a partner in our mission today?

Your donation is critical to the future of public service journalism. Support our work today – for as little as $5 – and help us keep making people smarter.