"Did Apple effectively work with China to burn a billion books in Tiananmen Square this weekend?"
Share Now on:
Earlier this year, China further tightened internet restrictions with a sweeping cyber-security law. But no one has really been able to figure out how this would affect businesses. Then, this past weekend, Apple pulled a bunch of virtual private network services, or VPNs, off its App Store “shelves” in China. The company said it made the move to comply with the new law.
In a country where the internet is highly censored, VPNs allow users to cloak their identity online. That means people can hide their IP addresses and access sites that have been blocked. VPNs aren’t illegal in China, so some say Apple removed VPN apps from its store because other electronics competitors are cutting into Apple’s profits, making the company more dependent on App Store sales.
Marketplace Tech’s Ben Johnson spoke with Sunday Yokubaitis, the president of Golden Frog, which makes VyprVPN, one of the products pulled from Apple’s App Store in China. Below is an edited excerpt of their conversation.
|The Chinese have their own Internet censorship song|
|3 ways to protect your online privacy|
Ben Johnson: You guys have a lot of customers in China. How worried are you about Apple taking services like yours out of the app store?
Sunday Yokubaitis: Could not be more disappointed in Apple. I view them as a beacon in some ways for what an American company should stand for. But then they went this weekend and worked with the Chinese government to remove the VPNs for Chinese users from the app store. The VPN is the internet in China. So did Apple effectively work with China to burn a billion books in Tiananmen Square this weekend? Because when you take a VPN down and you take the internet down that’s what you’re doing. You’re restricting information. And they seem to be valuing profits over human rights.
Johnson: What do people outside of China not understand about how people consume content there?
Yokubaitis: If you said to most users in the United States, “Go look at what you did and how you traverse the internet throughout the day,” and say, “We’re going to take away 80 percent of that,” that’s what the experience would be like. That would be kind of the black hole effect of what would happen.
Johnson: Can you talk about the tech of how that works?
Yokubaitis: At a basic level that most users can understand, they block our website. So what do we do? We create another website with another domain that the Chinese, through word of mouth, share with each other. And we do some advertising to work with people in China to get that word out so we create a parallel universe for our website. It’s a little bit cat and mouse — they they do something and we respond, but we have a lot of customers around the world and it’s not a make or break for us as a business. I think for us, it’s more important to stick to our principles and keep the internet open and free.
If you’re a member of your local public radio station, we thank you — because your support helps those stations keep programs like Marketplace on the air. But for Marketplace to continue to grow, we need additional investment from those who care most about what we do: superfans like you.
Your donation — as little as $5 — helps us create more content that matters to you and your community, and to reach more people where they are – whether that’s radio, podcasts or online.
When you contribute directly to Marketplace, you become a partner in that mission: someone who understands that when we all get smarter, everybody wins.