Shoppers at Target in Los Angeles. 
Shoppers at Target in Los Angeles.  - 
Listen To The Story

At a Target in downtown Los Angeles, Lauren Ireland exchanged a gift at the return counter just a few days before Christmas. She's not the only one, either. Asked if a store's return policy matters to her, she said, of course.

"I won’t buy it if I know I can’t return it,” she said. 

Target’s return policy is posted clearly behind the return cashier. The store will do "everything it can to ensure customer satisfaction" and "most unopened items returned within 90 days in new condition will receive a refund or exchange." But that’s Target’s particular policy. Angela Hausmann, a marketing professor at George Washington University, said retailers calculate their return policies with one thing in mind.

“They don’t have to do anything when the product is not defective, based on manufacturing," she said. "Businesses do this because of the good will that it generates with customers.”

Good will and loyalty. In a competitive marketplace, people can buy stocking stuffers anywhere. They can order them online and get them shipped to their homes. Regulators aren’t telling retailers they have to do anything to help the customer out.

“I think the biggest thing for consumers to understand is that there really are no legal protections for them," Hausmann said. "And if they have a really stringent return policy, you’re just out of luck.”

Returns cost retailers lots of money. Joe Colangelo, president of Consumers' Research, said it becomes a bigger issue when customers take advantage of a return policy.

“Fraudulent returns account for about four percent of all holiday returns," he said. "Just holiday sales alone, there’s going to be $2.2 billion in fraudulent returns.”

Some people call it “renting a product.” Someone needs a drill for a day, but doesn't need a drill all the time, so they go to a store with a liberal return policy, use the drill for a day and then take it back. Colangelo said there's nothing a retailer can do to change consumer behavior.

“People’s behavior is very difficult to change," he said. "There are a number of customers who are never going to take advantage of a return policy because they feel that it’s morally wrong. And then there are some people that, no matter how strict you make it, they’re going to find the loophole that allows them to get a little extra.”

But, believe it or not, a liberal return policy might lead to fewer returns. Stacy Wood, professor of marketing at North Carolina State University, did research into exactly that. She said it’s a psychological thing.

“Here’s what happens, here’s the mechanism: when consumers see a liberal return policy it’s a signal to them, a cue, that the retailer is standing behind their products," she said. "What happens is that there’s this tricky little psychological bias that we all fall prey to, which is called confirmatory bias. And what happens is that we tend to view evidence in a way that confirms our prior expectations.”

For many customers, a liberal return policy makes them think they’re shopping at a good store. Maybe that’s why L.L. Bean is willing to take back those 15-year-old cross country skis, no questions asked.

“I think the best compliment I can give is not to say how much your programs have taught me (a ton), but how much Marketplace has motivated me to go out and teach myself.” – Michael in Arlington, VA

As a nonprofit news organization, what matters to us is the same thing that matters to you: being a source for trustworthy, independent news that makes people smarter about business and the economy. So if Marketplace has helped you understand the economy better, make more informed financial decisions or just encouraged you to think differently, we’re asking you to give a little something back.

Become a Marketplace Investor today – in whatever amount is right for you – and keep public service journalism strong. We’re grateful for your support.

Follow Andy Uhler at @andy_uhler