New research by Princeton University economist Alexandre Mas and Harvard University economist Amanda Pallais sheds light on how much value workers place on alternative work arrangements.
In a research paper published by the National Bureau of Economic Research, the co-writers describe an experiment they conducted involving 7,000 online job seekers.
“We asked workers applying for a real job at a national call center for their preferences,” Mas said.
Choices the applicants were offered included a flexible schedule, working from home, a standard 9-to-5 schedule working Monday through Friday, and variable schedules set by the employer, including nighttime and weekend shifts. Varying hourly pay rates were offered along with the different work-schedule options to determine how much value the applicants would put on the accommodative schedules, and how much pay they would sacrifice to avoid the more onerous ones.
“They are not willing to take even a small 50 cent pay cut in order to have flexibility,” Mas said. “Workers, however, really like working from home.”
In fact, they’ll take an 8 percent cut in hourly pay to get to work from home. And they’ll take 20 percent less to get a regular 9-to-5 weekday schedule.
The most undesirable work arrangements for applicants were variable or unpredictable schedules set by the employer, Mas said, especially if they involved working nights, early mornings and weekends.
Andrew Stettner at the Century Foundation said that fits with the experience of many low-wage workers, especially in retail and hotels, bars and restaurants.
“Many hourly workers, who are still the majority of American workers, don’t really have consistent access to a regular 9-to-5 schedule,” Stettner said. “There’s an increasing share of workers who don’t know what their schedule is going to be like the next week.”
He said many employers have deployed scheduling software that managers use “to pinpoint exactly how many people they need on the floor, depending on different times of day, varying with sales. And they send people home" from scheduled shifts based on that real-time analysis to save on labor costs.
Mas and Pallais found that women put the most value on flexibility and working at home.
“I think the best compliment I can give is not to say how much your programs have taught me (a ton), but how much Marketplace has motivated me to go out and teach myself.” – Michael in Arlington, VABEFORE YOU GO