Update: As of Thursday, September 29, the FCC has indefinitely postponed its plans to vote on this proposal.
The Federal Communications Commission is holding a vote Thursday about getting rid of cable set-top boxes — those generic, clunky boxes currently costing you $230 for the privilege of watching TV.
Tom Wheeler, the chairman of the FCC, has instead been pushing a plan that would allow cable subscribers to get all those shows through an app.
A slam dunk of an idea if ever there was one, right? Yeah, not so fast.
The proposal would require cable companies to offer a free app allowing customers to access programming from their devices, including smart TVs, tablets, smartphones, etc.
But, that’s not as simple as it sounds, said Congressman Tony Cárdenas, a Democrat from California.
“The basic issue, not complicated. How to get it done, very complicated,” Cárdenas said.
Cárdenas is one of 64 members of Congress who sent a letter to Wheeler, raising concerns that the app ruling could upend complex and competitive licensing agreements.
“It’s copyright, it’s intellectual property, it’s who gets to be allowed to unlock someone’s information,” he said.
Cárdenas also questioned whether the FCC has the jurisdiction to mandate these agreements.
Wheeler’s plan came under fire at a Senate Commerce Committee hearing earlier this month, where Democrats joined Republicans in criticizing the plan’s copyright licensing arrangement.
FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel expressed her own uneasiness.
“The FCC is getting a little bit too involved in the licensing scheme here, ” she said.
Rosenworcel is a Democrat whose vote is needed for the measure’s passage since the two Republican commissioners are expected to oppose it.
John Bergmayer, an attorney at Public Knowledge, a consumer advocacy group, said apps won’t change anything about cable’s fundamental business model.
“This isn’t a la carte, this isn’t breaking up the cable bundle, or anything like that. This is just saying that whatever the existing bundle is, people should access it on devices they might already have,” Bergmayer said.
Even if the proposal passes, Bergmayer said it could still be two years out until compliance kicks in.
There’s a lot happening in the world. Through it all, Marketplace is here for you.
You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible.
Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.