Farm families in the west under pressure to sell their water

Marketplace Contributor Sep 1, 2016
Auctioneer Spanky Assiter calls bids for land and water rights at a real estate auction in Loveland, Colorado.  Luke Runyon/KUNC and Harvest Public Media

Farm families in the west under pressure to sell their water

Marketplace Contributor Sep 1, 2016
Auctioneer Spanky Assiter calls bids for land and water rights at a real estate auction in Loveland, Colorado.  Luke Runyon/KUNC and Harvest Public Media

Few things are more valuable to a farmer in the arid West than irrigation water. Without it, the land turns back to its natural state: dry, dusty plains.

If a fast-growing city is your neighbor, then your water holds even more value.

Farm families in Western states like Colorado are increasingly under pressure to sell their water. It’s been coined “buy and dry,” as water is diverted from farm fields and instead used to fill pipes in condos and subdivisions.

Buy and dry deals are usually cut behind closed doors, in quiet, unassuming meetings. A city approaches a farmer, or a farmer approaches a city, and strikes a deal. But a recent public auction in Loveland, Colorado threw the doors wide open, bringing myriad bidders and interests into one room to duke it out. It gives a glimpse of the unique stresses and opportunities farmers face in parched portions of the West.

Bidders, some in cowboy hats, some in business suits, packed the room at the Larimer County Fairgrounds. Abuzz with a sort of nervous energy, audience members whispered about how high the prices might climb. Auctioneer Spanky Assiter took the mic, and laid out the stakes.

“Today’s an opportunity to buy water,” he said. “You see commercials on TV all the time, invest in gold, invest in silver, invest in natural resources. There’s nothing more valuable than water.”

An auction of this size, with hundreds of individual water rights from a massive reservoir system called the Colorado-Big Thompson project and more than a dozen shares of a local ditch company up for grabs,  is rare. The Colorado-Big Thompson project moves water from Colorado’s Western Slope through reservoirs, canals and tunnels to provide water for Front Range municipalities and farmers.

There are also more than 400 acres of farmland up for grabs, but that’s not the asset that packed the room. Even though the tracts sit just 40 miles from Denver, one of the fastest-growing metro areas in the country, the water that flows into the fields is worth much more.

An assistant with Hall and Hall, the auction company that organized the gathering in Loveland, keeps track of bids for tracts of land and water rights. 

Scotti Reynolds, who ran a cattle operation on the property with her husband until his death in 2012, has been contemplating how and when to sell the property. “The land and the water have become more valuable than the income from farming,” she said.

When the bidding begins, auction assistants weave into the crowd, find the bidders and shouting back and forth to keep the bid climbing higher and higher.

One by one, water shares find new owners in the crowd. When all is said and done, the water rights alone went for close to $10 million. The land went for $3 million. By far, the biggest spenders were cities,  like Broomfield, a Denver suburb.

“It’s not cheap, but you only pay for it once. You buy it once and you get it forever,” says Melanie Calvert, who works in Broomfield’s water resources department and purchases water rights for the city.

At the auction she bid $3.2 million of taxpayer money for 120 shares of Colorado-Big Thompson water, each one fetching about $27,000, more than double for what the same amount of water cost a decade ago. The city’s purchase continues a longtime trend. Increasingly, water is more sought after for lawn sprinklers and bathroom faucets than for growing hay for cows.

Broomfield’s been on a tear in the water market. The city’s spent $12.6 million since the beginning of 2016 on acquiring water, with another $2.6 million deal in the works. Hardly the only city buttressing water supplies by buying up agricultural water rights, it’s  just following in the footsteps of Thornton and Aurora, other Colorado cities with reputations for buying lots of water.

The Colorado Water Plan, a recently-adopted statewide steering document, laments the fact that auctions like this even exist. It attempts to offer up alternatives, some of which are still theoretical because of the legal wrangling and economic conditions needed to bring them to fruition.

A statewide water supply study in 2010 estimated that by 2050, Colorado could lose 500,000 to 700,000 acres of currently irrigated farmland to keep water flowing into cities if “buy and dry” continues at its current pace.

There’s plenty of angst in the farming community about cities buying water, drying up farmland and putting in condos, Calvert said. But cities have water needs too. “No one’s twisting anyone’s arm,” she said. “I’m not trying to get anyone to close down their farm or anything like that. If you want to sell your water, come and talk to me.”

That kind of talk could appeal to farmers like Kent Peppler. He’s a half mile down the road from the auctioned farmland. These days he’s often driving his tractors through suburban neighborhoods to plant and harvest his crops.

“I’ve been feeling penned in for quite a few years now,” he said with a laugh.

Peppler said more of his neighbors are paying attention to auctions like this. Million dollar checks are tempting, even for multi-generational farm families. For him, there’s a real worry that at some point agriculture in water-stressed parts of the West could cease to exist.

“If commodity prices stay low, then definitely this will be a benchmark for people to think about,” Peppler said.

With many fond memories wrapped up in the property, the auctioned farm’s owner, Scotti Reynolds, admitted it stings to sell the land and water. There was no family member willing to take over the farm, and with water bringing record high prices, now’s the time to take advantage.

 “History proves that change comes, whether we’re happy with it or not,” she said. 

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.