Are sport retail bankruptcies Darwinism at work?

Jed Kim Apr 18, 2016
HTML EMBED:
COPY
Sports Chalet operated in a crowded space of sports retailers including Sports Authority, Dick's Sporting Goods and REI.  Tim Boyle/Getty Images

Are sport retail bankruptcies Darwinism at work?

Jed Kim Apr 18, 2016
Sports Chalet operated in a crowded space of sports retailers including Sports Authority, Dick's Sporting Goods and REI.  Tim Boyle/Getty Images
HTML EMBED:
COPY

The sporting goods retail industry continues to see upheavals, as Vestis Retail Group filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy on Monday. As part of its restructuring plan, the parent company will shutter dozens of the stores it owns, including eight Eastern Mountain Sports and all 47 of its Sports Chalet locations. 

That comes less than two months after one of the leading retail chains, Sports Authority, filed for bankruptcy. Industry experts said failures in online sales and a glut of competition led to the financial challenges. 

“You’ve got way too many stores selling too much similar product. Some of them need to go away,” said Jeff Harbaugh, a consultant for small-to-mid market active outdoor companies. 

He said Sports Chalet’s focus on selling a variety of high-priced products to committed outdoor enthusiasts didn’t work for the size of the chain. 

“I think it’s really hard to do that and be 40 stores. I think maybe if you’re three stores you can do it, or if you’re a hundred stores, you can do it,” Harbaugh said. 

Sports Authority’s bankruptcy filing may highlight the limited market space for multiple major chains within an industry. John Horan, publisher of Sporting Goods Intelligence, said the industry already has two major players in Dick’s Sporting Goods and Academy Sports + Outdoors. 

“There just aren’t many examples where three big box concepts really survive in a single industry,” Horan said.

“Retailing’s the most Darwinian business there is. Eventually, somebody gets out there and becomes the most important retailer and becomes the gatekeeper to the consumer for the brands,” he said. 

Horan said Dick’s is well situated to benefit from the restructuring of its competitors. 

“One of the things that will happen with the Sports Authority bankruptcy is that all of the Sports Authority leases will be auctioned off,” Horan said. “That’s going to give Dick’s a tremendous opportunity to increase its presence in the California and West Coast market, which it is in now, but probably not to the degree that it would like to be.” 

He said despite the losses, the industry as a whole stands to gain, once stock liquidation sales are finished. 

“There’s definitely going to be a disruption over the first half of this year, and then the second half of the year, it should be considerably healthier,” he said. 

As a nonprofit news organization, our future depends on listeners like you who believe in the power of public service journalism.

Your investment in Marketplace helps us remain paywall-free and ensures everyone has access to trustworthy, unbiased news and information, regardless of their ability to pay.

Donate today — in any amount — to become a Marketplace Investor. Now more than ever, your commitment makes a difference.