A lie detector test, 1937. Keystone/Getty Images

How much would you lie to save a few bucks?

Tony Wagner Mar 17, 2016
A lie detector test, 1937. Keystone/Getty Images

Have you ever lied to save money? No? Put it this way: ever shared a Netflix password? That counts.

A third of Americans say password sharing is an acceptable lie, according to a new survey released by NerdWallet this week. The site talked to 2,118 people and asked them if a series of money-saving lies were acceptable: everything from fudging ages for a discount to hiding “under the table” income to save on taxes. Weirdly, respondents found that last one — a felony! — the second-most acceptable, after sharing passwords.

The whole thing got us curious — do any of our listeners do this? I put the question out on Twitter.

To be fair, I’ll let you know that I still take advantage of student discounts whenever I can even though I graduated from college two years ago, and if I ever tell you I streamed a TV show, it was certainly using a borrowed password. Probably most egregiously, I’ve used every email address I have (five) to send myself referral discounts on online food delivery.

Now that my dirty laundry’s out there, let’s see what you all confessed:

(Very) petty theft

I’d put password-sharing in this category too, along with the person who messaged me to say she gets around her local newspaper’s online paywall.

Still a student at heart

This was by far the most common grift I heard from friends and Marketplace listeners, but weirdly only 17 percent of the people NerdWallet surveyed said they thought it was acceptable to lie about your own age to get a discount. That said, younger people were more likely to say lying about their age was OK.

Lying to other people

This was a more common one than I thought — people talked about conning not a big faceless entity like Netflix or the government, but telling little (sometimes white, sometimes less white) lies to other people to save money.

“[I tell my] girlfriend I order the well whiskey when really I order Jack Daniels single barrel,” one guy told me in a Twitter direct message. Another person said she’ll invent work or school obligations to get out of things that aren’t in her budget — like big expensive birthday dinners.

“Frequently I’d much rather drink a gold rush & watch ‘Great British Bake-Off’ on my couch than be stuck at the bad end of a table for 12,” she said.

Insurance and taxes

These are the biggies. One guy messaged me to say he lied about his income for a discount on his electric bill, another told me how he saves on insurance: “State Farm thinks I still live with my parents. I’m 29. But for 20 percent off my car insurance, it’s fine with me if they think I’m a loser.”

Marketplace is on a mission.

We believe Main Street matters as much as Wall Street, economic news is made relevant and real through human stories, and a touch of humor helps enliven topics you might typically find…well, dull.

Through the signature style that only Marketplace can deliver, we’re on a mission to raise the economic intelligence of the country—but we don’t do it alone. We count on listeners and readers like you to keep this public service free and accessible to all. Will you become a partner in our mission today?

Your donation is critical to the future of public service journalism. Support our work today – for as little as $5 – and help us keep making people smarter.