The organizations that lend student money aren't the real lenders. m00by/Flickr
Marketplace Whiteboard®

Why relaxing terms on student loans could backfire

Paddy Hirsch Sep 24, 2015
The organizations that lend student money aren't the real lenders. m00by/Flickr

Here’s a problem with the idea of taking it easier on student borrowers: Wall Street doesn’t like it.

So what, you say. Students can’t handle all the debt they’re borrowing. We need debt forgiveness and easier terms. Wall Street should just suck it up.

Except that when Wall Street doesn’t like something, it tends not to suck it up. It tends to walk away.

And if Wall Street walks away from the student debt market, then students will find it impossible to borrow.

Why? Because those organizations that lend student money aren’t the real lenders. They sell the loans that they make to other people, who then package those loans and spin bonds off them, which are then sold to Wall Street types, like investment houses, mutual and pension funds.

This is a process called securitization, and you can watch a short video on how it works here:

Securitization turns government and private lenders into lending machines, because they can make loans, sell them off, and then make more loans. So long as Wall Street wants to keep buying the bonds that are spun off these packages of loans, the lenders can keep lending. But if demand starts to fall off, the “bundlers” won’t be able to buy loans from the lenders, which means those lenders won’t be able to make those loans.

And demand will fall off, if programs designed to give students more time to pay back their loans mean they fail to make the regular interest payments that are the lifeblood of a securitization. If investors think there’s a danger they might not get an interest payment every month, they’ll look for other bonds to buy.

Or they’ll demand more in interest for the increased risk, and that will drive the interest rates on student debt even higher.

Leaving students badly in need of a drink. Which they won’t be able to afford.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.