Britain’s Crystal Palace could rise again

Stephen Beard Oct 11, 2013

Britain’s Crystal Palace could rise again

Stephen Beard Oct 11, 2013

A Chinese property developer has unveiled plans for a $800 million building project in south London. Ni Zhaoxing from Shanghai wants to recreate the Crystal Palace, the Victorian cast iron and plate glass masterpiece which burned down in the 1930s.

But Mr. Ni’s plan to rebuild it is getting mixed reviews.

“Mr. Ni has come forward with a brilliant, original and simple vision,” declares the mayor of London, Boris Johnson. The mayor welcomes the idea of building a replica of the huge structure, high on a hill in the same London park where it stood for more than 80 years.

“South London will once again acquire a world class, cultural attraction,” Johnson claims. “The park will be reborn. And the Palace will rise again.”

Design and culture critic Stephen Bayley takes a much more jaundiced view. He argues that the new building will be a pale reflection of the original, which was built to house the Great Exhibition of 1851, an international showcase for technological innovation. Since Britain dominated the global economy at that time, says Bayley, the old Palace embodied British imperial pride.

“It was such a monument to confidence and vigor and a refusal to compromise,” he points out. “It was Britain having the nerve, indeed audacity to say: ‘Look! We actually own the planet.’”

Bayley, who doesn’t like architectural replicas, predicts that the new Palace will just be “muddled kitsch.” Like other architectural fakes in China — the Champs Elysees with a stunted Eiffel Tower in Hangzhou, or Thames Town in Shanghai.

Residents who live near the Crystal Palace Park are nervous about the planned development. “Who knows what this ‘Victorian reconstruction’ could turn into?” wonders John Payne, head of the Crystal Palace Community Association. “It could become a huge pop concert venue, a shopping mall, a big casino. The list is endless.”

The possible re-creation of one of the architectural glories of the Victorian era does not impress Audrey Hammond, a founding member of the Community Association.

“What is most valuable to thousands of Londoners who live in this very built-up area,” she says, “is this open space, the trees, the plants, the animals the birds. This is the most wonderful open space, a green lung for Londoners. And this is what we need. Not more development, more building, more money-making schemes to take away our precious bit of open space.”

The Chinese developer, Mr. Ni, is pressing ahead with his plan for what he says will be a “jewel in Britain’s crown” and which will pay its way as a concert, convention and exhibition center — with a six-star hotel thrown in.

Mr. Ni has some powerful support. His project is not only backed by the mayor of London but also by Stephen Carr, head of the local council, which owns the Crystal Palace site.

“ It’s clear to me that this is a great opportunity for the area,” says Carr. “And I and the council certainly wouldn’t be behind it if we didn’t think it was going to have huge benefit for the local people.”

Local residents have a year to register their objections. If the plan gets the go-ahead, construction will begin in the winter of 2015.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.  

Need some Econ 101?

Our new Marketplace Crash Course is here to help. Sign-up for free, learn at your own pace.