Reconsidering digital devices at takeoff and landing

Molly Wood Aug 29, 2012

Know how you have to turn off your Kindle when you’re on a plane, at least when you take off and land? The FAA is asking for public comment on those rules.

Jay Apt is a professor at Carnegie Mellon’s Tepper School of Business. He says, “You have a Wi-Fi card in your laptop or your iPad, you have of course a radio in your cell phone, and if those things are pumping out radio waves, they can interfere with the navigation and control systems of the airliners.”

There are two ways digital devices cause problems. Kenneth Kirchoff is an engineer from Boeing. He calls the first front door interference: “Emissions from devices that are unintentional that are actually in the same frequency as the radios that are used on the airplane, so that energy gets out of the airplane, gets out through the windows and doors and things like that and it couples onto the airplane antennas because it’s in the same frequency and can interfere with those radio devices, such as navigation equipment or surveillance equipment.”

The second: back door interference. “And that’s when you have the intentional emissions from a cell phone or a Wi-Fi device where that intentional signal that’s being radiated can couple onto wiring or it can couple directly into the systems on the airplane and cause some sort of interference with those systems,” says Kirchoff.

Back to Jay Apt. He’s done research that shows the interference can be a problem. “In about a half a dozen incidents, the flight crew identified the personal electronic device, had the passenger turn it off, saw the navigation error went away, and then had them turn it back on again and then saw the navigation error recurred, and then of course had it stowed for flight, so we were convinced that these kind of errors, while rare, are real, and when an airliner is speeding close to the ground on a foggy day trying to get into New Orleans before a hurricane strikes, you really want all the navigation systems to be working just fine.”

Boeing’s Kirchoff says devices like the Kindle might not be so bad. “When that device is operating just as a book, and it’s not transmitting anything, in that kind of a mode, it’s certainly from an electromagnetic standpoint isn’t going to interfere, or shouldn’t interfere with the airplane.”

He says there are still reasons you might not be able to keep your Kindle out at takeoff and landing. For one, it’s hard to police whether your device is in airplane mode plus airlines want you to pay attention to those safety announcements.

One thing not up for discussion, cell phone calls. Those are prohibited by the Federal Communications Commission.


And now from the files of sci-fi-inspired technology.

Researchers have figured out how to hack into our brains.

“Invasion of the Body Snatchers” clip: They will absorb your mind…your memories.

Or at least get a better guess of what’s in there. Scientists, using a couple-hundred-dollar brain computer interface headset, were able to pick up subconscious activities. And use those signals to help figure out research subjects’ PIN numbers, even which house they live in.

In the future, you could use these headsets to play video games. But you might want to be careful. Because while you’re playing games, hackers could read all your brain data and use it against you.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.