Campaign Trail

Are Romney’s drilling plans eco-friendly?

Molly Wood Aug 24, 2012
Campaign Trail

Are Romney’s drilling plans eco-friendly?

Molly Wood Aug 24, 2012

Mitt Romney has announced a new energy plan he says will lead to greater energy independence if he’s elected. The plan calls for states to have greater authority to allow drilling on federal lands within their borders.

What would that drilling mean for those lands? For one thing, the drilling would be faster than before.

“Drilling efficiency has improved mostly because of the progress of information technology and drilling techniques,” says Tad Patzek, chair of the Department of Petroleum and Geosystems Engineering at the University of Texas at Austin. “Not only the drilling bits got better, but the way we put them in and yank them out from the hole and the way we drill has improved, so the speed of drilling today is two to four times probably what it was even a couple of years ago.”

Drilling technology has made huge leaps forward but it’s still drilling and still has impact.

Patzek: I want to dispel the myth that all activities have no environment cost. They do. And so the question we have to ask ourselves is what is more important to us? Unspoiled landscape or oil and gas? And very often, in my mind at least, the answer to this question is far from clear.

Moe: You’ve talked about how much faster these are than previous technologies. Has the environmental footprint improved accordingly?

Patzek: Yes. So there are rig manufacturers who radically redesigned the rigs and for example make rigs that do not use mud pits, they use closed containers which are very easily assembled and disassembled in a very safe and clean way. In addition to that, because of the directional drilling and because of the progress of measurement while drilling and the other things that we do, from one location, very often you can drill several wells and that also decreases the environmental footprint.

Patzek says it’s not the rigs themselves that would have the big effect on the environment.

Patzek: It comes in the form of excess roads, power lines, pipelines, all kinds of other things which have a much larger footprint than the wells themselves.

Moe: It’s the infrastructure around the wells?

Patzek: Absolutely.


There are SO many political ads coming your way this fall. They’re going to make claims about how wonderful their candidate is and how the opponent has done horrible things.

And you’ll wonder, is that really true?

Well, technology to the rescue. The new non-partisan SuperPACApp helps you sort out the real deal from the baloney, the malarkey, the bull.

I have it on my phone here. I turn it on, hold it up to a campaign commercial.

Ad: Romney’s plan could cut college aid for nearly 10 million students. And eliminate the tax deduction for college tuition.

It works like the music app Shazam, if you’ve ever seen that. It recognizes the ad, shows you the claims the ad makes and tells you what groups like Politifact and have to say about them.

And yes, it works on both parties.

Ad: On July 12th, Obama quietly ended work requirements for welfare. You wouldn’t have to work and wouldn’t have to train for a job.

I’ll spare you the picking apart of all these claims. It’s complicated. And long. Here’s what the SuperPACApp ultimately does. It invites you to stop accepting everything a politician tells you at face value. And it invites you to do a little research of your own.

That’s good for democracy, right?

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.