What to expect from the health care hearing

Gregory Warner Mar 26, 2012

Stacey Vanek Smith: President Obama’s health care reform is having its day in court. For the next three days, the Supreme Court will hear arguments about the constitutionality of several aspects of the overhaul.

Our own Gregory Warner will be there today. Good morning, Gregory.

Gregory Warner: Good morning.

Vanek Smith: So “Constitutional Woodstock” — this sounds so interesting to me. Tell me a little bit about what you expect.

Warner: Well, come on, first of all, it’s an important case. But also, right outside the Supreme Court building, everybody’s going to be gathered — you’ve got your Tea Party; you have other protesters in support, of course, of the law. It’ll be a scene.

Vanek Smith: So why is such a long debate? Why three days? The Supreme Court hasn’t scheduled an argument this long since the ’60s, from what I understand.

Warner: That’s right. The three days are broken up like this: Day 1 is can the court even hear this case?; Day 2 is the big question — can Congress tell Americans they have to buy health insurance, this individual mandate?; and then Day 3, if the Supreme Court does strike down this mandate, what else in the law do they have to get rid of?

Vanek Smith: Talk to me about that last question: If the individual mandate goes, what happens to the rest of the health care law?

Warner: There’s an economics answer, and then there’s a politics answer, and then I guess a geographic answer to this question. So basically, the mandate is the linchpin of the law — it allows insurance reform because insurance only works if people buy when they don’t think they need it. Now, there’s lots of policy ways to do that. The problem is politics, because any of these solutions would have to be agreed to by Congress, so there’s that. Geographically, if this law gets struck down, nothing’s stopping states from doing the same thing, so it depends where you live.

Vanek Smith: So Gregory, tell us what happens if the Supreme Court upholds this law?

Warner: Well that’s then — legally — the end of the line, but then there’s November, the presidential election, of course. That’s another mandate on this law politically. And then in 2014, remember the states have to be a partner with the federal government in implementing this law, so states could pretty easily drag their heels or even flout this law. And then again, it depends on the politics, whether the politics of 2014 look like the politics of today.

Vanek Smith: Our own Gregory Warner, who will be at the argument a little bit later today. Gregory, we hope to hear updates from you.

Warner: I’ll be joining you.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.