Power Marketplace’s public service journalism 💙 Give Now
Financial expert Carmen Wong Ulrich says credit cards aren't bad -- until you start looking at them as free cash. iStockphoto

Can you handle a credit card?

Tess Vigeland Nov 17, 2011
Financial expert Carmen Wong Ulrich says credit cards aren't bad -- until you start looking at them as free cash. iStockphoto

Tess Vigeland: So every time we talk about credit cards on this program, we get letters from two listener camps. One argues no one should use credit cards EVER. No way. No how. Evil incarnate. The other says, Hey, stop vilifying credit cards. Cards don’t get people into debt — people do!

Well, we’re going to revisit the issue today with our friend Carmen Wong Ulrich, author of “The Real Cost of Living.” Welcome back!

Carmen Wong Ulrich: Thank you Tess. Thanks for having me.

Vigeland: So given all the news lately, do you think it’s a wise decision to switch over from credit to debit? I mean, what are the real benefits of using debit over credit?

Ulrich: I’m a fan of the other way around — of actually using credit over debit. I just don’t think credit cards are evil in and of themselves. And actually, the majority of Americans — 80 percent of Americans who use credit cards have no trouble with credit cards and don’t carry a balance.

Vigeland: Wait a minute, I’m going to stop you there. Eighty percent of Americans don’t carry a balance?

Ulrich: Exactly. But the ones who do carry a balance, carry an incredibly high balance. So that really skews the numbers.

Vigeland: But it sounds to me like the real kicker there is that you have to be actively paying attention and actively managing your credit card. I mean, at least with a debit card, there aren’t as many fees. And in fact, the banks have started backing off that recently. But boy, you can rack up interest charges, you can rack up all kinds of fees with credit cards.

Ulrich: Sure.

Vigeland: So you really have to pay attention.

Ulrich: Yes. I always say to folks, you know, what it comes to this question, know yourself. Are you someone who’s going to carry a balance? Are you able to spend within them? If not, then don’t use credit cards. I recommend to build credit than just rotate a couple of cards and use them for only one specific thing. For example, use a gas card just for gas. But make sure that you have these limits on yourself if you know you’re not going to be able to handle it.

Vigeland: All right, let’s get to my main question, which is one that listeners write in quite often about, which is how many credit cards is kind of a good rule of thumb? Is it a good idea to have multiple cards?

Ulrich: There’s no magic number, but I always recommend folks at least have two or three credit cards. A lot of your credit report and credit score is based on length of credit history, but also how much credit you have available to you versus how much you’re actually using. So let’s say you only have one card and it has a limit of $10,000. You have $3,000 in expenses a month. You have pay it off in full, but that card looks like that it’s almost 30 percent utilized. So that’s dangerous, because it makes your credit score go down.

Vigeland: But then again, you just have to be careful that you’re not staring at that thing in your wallet and going, “Well, maybe I can put a little something on there…”

Ulrich: Tess, you’re talking about yourself here, aren’t you?

Vigeland: No, no!

Ulrich: This is the thing: You have to look at credit cards as financial tools for emergency and for use to build your credit, for the perks that can come with it. But the second you start carrying the balance, they turn into a bad thing.

Vigeland: Yup.

Ulrich: With this economy, with this job market, it’s not a bad thing to have as much credit at your disposal as long as you don’t use it, should you find yourself out of work for an extended period of time, or should your find yourself needing to lean on it. Credit cards got distorted. They never should’ve been thought of as a tool to basically get great shoes, bags, you know, dining out — whatever it is. Never should’ve been thought of as that.

Vigeland: You mentioned a couple of times that credit cards, one of the real benefits is if you can manage them well and then take advantage of a lot of the perks and the reward programs that are out there. But isn’t it true that most of the cards that have rewards are also going to charge you some sort of annual fee for that. How do you balance that annual fee against the potential rewards?

Ulrich: Well, it depends on how much you use the card. Myself my example, my annual fee is $45. Now, they keep on sending me notices to upgrade to another card that has more perks, but costs 10 times that a year. I have no use for that. You really need to know yourself and your credit behavior to know if you $75 or $150 or $450 — when does it make sense to make that annual fee and that annual payment? When you talk about when you swipe, that vendor, they were getting charged quite a bit on debit cards. But they also get charged more when you swipe a reward card. So it’s just something to keep in mind if you know a small business owner and you’re close with them, maybe you wanna spare them that 12 percent fee or whatever it is that they get to pay for the rewards that you get. It’s a very, you know, interesting system.

Vigeland: All right. Carmen, thanks. It’s good to talk to you again.

Ulrich: Thank you Tess.

Vigeland: And if you want even MORE arguments for and against both debit and credit, we’ve got ’em on our Makin’ Money blog.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.  

This is NOT a paywall. 

Marketplace is community-funded public service journalism. Give in any amount that works for you – what matters is that you give today.