Chinese students, too qualified to be true?

Rob Schmitz Nov 9, 2011

Chinese students, too qualified to be true?

Rob Schmitz Nov 9, 2011

We tell you this all the time but it bears repeating as a way to set up this next story. For all the ills the global economy’s having right now, China’s having none of it. GDP growth there last quarter was 9.1 percent.

It’s creating a lot of wealth and all that new money means opportunities that, for years, a lot of Chinese could only dream of. Like — just for instance — sending your child to an American university. But getting into school there and getting into school here aren’t the same thing. Chinese high schoolers take one test for all the marbles. Here we’ve got the SATs, teacher recommendations, students essays, transcripts. So China’s now got a booming industry of college-placement companies that — for the right price — promise to secure a spot in an American school.

Our China Correspondent Rob Schmitz has the first of two stories about the controversial agencies that help Chinese students get into U.S. schools.

Rob Schmitz: If you walk down the street in Shanghai, it’s hard to miss the advertisements for college placement agencies. In big bold letters, they promise — some even guarantee — your child’s admission to an American university. The price: $5,000, $6,000, sometimes $7,000.

Jiang Xueqin is a well-known education reformer in China. He also heads the International division at Peking University High School — one of China’s best high schools. He has followed college placement agencies for years. He says this is how many of them deliver on their admission promises: they falsify students application materials.

Jiang Xueqin: There’s a lot of pressure on the agencies to write the application essays, to fake transcripts, to fake recommendation letters. This is just general business practice in China to falsify a lot of documentation.

A report by consulting firm Zinch China seems to confirm this. Zinch advises American colleges and universities on recruiting Chinese students. The firm interviewed agents and admissions consultants, as well as more than 200 Beijing students headed to U.S. schools. Zinch estimates 90 percent of these students submitted false recommendation letters; 70 percent had other people write their personal essays, and half of them submitted forged high school transcripts. Two former employees of a college placement agency told Marketplace they routinely falsified application materials. We did not use their names, because they feared they would lose their current jobs.

Anonymous employee 1: I wrote reference letters on behalf of students’ teachers and bosses. They were never willing to spend time to do this, so I just wrote them myself and they signed their names.

She worked for Shanghai Shenyuan, a placement agency connected to the University of Shanghai. It’s one of more than 400 agencies licensed by China’s government.

Here’s how the agency works: A student comes to Shanghai Shenyuan for help getting into a U.S. school. If Shenyuan succeeds, the agency collects — usually from the parents — the equivalent of $6,000. Both former employees say this put pressure on them to make absolutely sure that students were admitted to a U.S. college, even if they didn’t have the grades to get in.

Anonymous employee 2: They’d definitely not be accepted to American colleges with their transcripts. But if students tell their high schools they’re applying to an American college, most schools will revise their grades to reflect a B or an A average.

The reason, this former employee said, was simple.

Anonymous employee 2: So that they can boast that their students are admitted by well-known American colleges.

Both employees estimated they wrote college application essays for three out of every four students the agency handled.

Anonymous employee 1: I usually just made them up using my own ideas. Sometimes I’d browse the internet or read magazines for inspiration.

Over the years, Shanghai Shenyuan has had partnerships with more than a dozen U.S. universities, including the University of Wisconsin at Stevens Point. For weeks, Shanghai Shenyuan’s director ignored Marketplace’s repeated requests for an interview. But then we approached the University of Wisconsin and shared what we had found. That university promptly terminated its relationship with Shenyuan. The next day, Zhang Hong, Shanghai Shenyuan’s director, contacted us.

Zhang Hong: These are serious allegations and we are shocked. Faking application material is absolutely not allowed at Shenyuan.

Zhang says he’s investigating his agents for any wrongdoing.

Jim Miller, former president of the National Association for College Admission Counseling in the United States, says he’s not surprised at what Marketplace found.

Jim Miller: There are numerous colleges that are having difficulty assuring the integrity of the essays, transcripts and credentials, coming from other countries, and in particular in Asia.

Peking University High School’s Jiang Xueqin says both the agencies and American universities benefit from the status quo.

Jiang Xueqin: From an education perspective, what is happening is terrible. But from a business perspective, what’s happening makes perfect sense.

There are now more than 130,000 students from China at U.S. universities. Many of them paying full tuition. They make up nearly 20 percent of all foreign students and this percentage is only expected to grow in the years to come.

In Shanghai, I’m Rob Schmitz for Marketplace.

Ryssdal: Tomorrow Amy Scott’s got the flip side of the story. American schools, eager for tuition, facing a growing tide of Chinese applicants who may or may not be the students they say they are.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.