Background on the New Frugality
Here is some background on the idea of what I’m calling the New Frugality. It’s a theme that explains much of what is going on with the economy.
First, a cover story by Mike Mandel for Business Week laid out the basic idea:
The Consumer Crunch
Recession or not, American families will be forced to tighten their belts
The long-awaited, long-feared consumer crunch may finally be here. That might not mean an economywide recession, but the pain for American households will be deep.
In recent years the U.S. mostly has seen narrowly focused downturns, where a few sectors are hit hard while the rest of the economy and financial markets remain relatively unscathed. In the dot-com bust of 2001, for example, tech companies and stocks took it on the chin, while consumer spending and borrowing sailed through without a pause. This time the positions will be reversed, as consumers tank while much of the corporate sector stays on track.
It’s been a glorious run for the consumer. In the past 25 years, Americans have kept shopping through good times and bad. In every quarter except one since 1981, consumer spending rose over the previous year, adjusted for inflation. The exception was the first quarter of 1991, and even then the decrease was a mild 0.4% dip.
The main fuel for the spending was easy access to credit. Banks and other financial institutions were willing to lend households ever increasing amounts of money. Any particular individual might default, but in the aggregate, loans to consumers were viewed as low-risk and profitable.
The subprime crisis, however, marks the beginning of the end for the long consumer borrow-and-buy boom. The financial sector, wrestling with hundreds of billions in losses, can no longer treat consumers as a safe bet. Already, standards for real estate lending have been raised, including those for jumbo mortgages for high-end houses. Credit cards are still widely available, but it may only be a matter of time before issuers get tougher.
What comes next could be scary–the largest pullback in consumer spending in decades, perhaps as much as $200 billion to $300 billion, or 2%-3% of personal income. Reduced access to credit will combine with falling real estate values to hit poor and rich alike. “We’re in uncharted territory,” says David Rosenberg, chief North American economist at Merrill Lynch (MER ), who’s forecasting a mild drop in consumer spending in the first half of 2008. “It’s pretty rare we go through such a pronounced tightening in credit standards.”
You can read the full story here.
I followed up with a story looking into the personal finance implications of thrift:
How to Survive the Credit Crunch
by Chris Farrell
Driving along the Interstate on the outskirts of Minnesota’s Twin Cities, you can’t miss the nation’s largest mall. A massive citadel of consumerism, the Mall of America boasts some 520 stores in a space big enough to hold 32 Boeing 747s. Spend a few hours there and big numbers stop fazing you–numbers like the record $2.5 trillion in U.S. household debt, which rises to $13.6 trillion with mortgages tossed in. Bigger is better, you say, with a wink, charging that 52-inch flat-screen TV. Yet the credit crunch could mark a major turning point for the U.S. consumer economy. Half a century of spend-with-abandon attitude may be winding down. The shift won’t come about because consumers embrace a new frugality. What’s happening is that the average consumer now looks like a towering risk to the folks who extended all the debt–credit-card companies, mortgage lenders, and, most recently, student loan outfits. And those lenders are pulling back, making it harder to borrow.
That doesn’t mean the Mall of America is going to empty out like New York City in the new Will Smith movie I Am Legend. But the fallout from tougher lending standards should be making you think about adjusting your financial strategy, from plotting your portfolio to figuring how you’ll finance home purchases and college educations. Says Ross Levin, a certified financial planner and president of Accredited Investors in Edina, Minn.: “The implications are gigantic when it comes to personal finance.”
You can read about those implications for home ownership, stocks, bonds, credit cards and student loans here.
The New York Times caught up with the idea earlier this week:
Economy Fitful, Americans Start to Pay as They Go
By PETER S. GOODMAN
For more than half a century, Americans have proved staggeringly resourceful at finding new ways to spend money.
In the 1950s and ’60s, as credit cards grew in popularity, many began dining out when the mood struck or buying new television sets on the installment plan rather than waiting for payday. By the 1980s, millions of Americans were entrusting their savings to the booming stock market, using the winnings to spend in excess of their income. Millions more exuberantly borrowed against the value of their homes.
But now the freewheeling days of credit and risk may have run their course– at least for a while and perhaps much longer– as a period of involuntary thrift unfolds in many households. With the number of jobs shrinking, housing prices falling and debt levels swelling, the same nation that pioneered the no-money-down mortgage suddenly confronts an unfamiliar imperative: more Americans must live within their means.
“We don’t use our credit cards anymore,” said Lisa Merhaut, a professional at a telecommunications company who lives in Leesburg, Va., and whose family last year ran up credit card debt it could not handle.
Today, Ms. Merhaut, 44, manages her money the way her father did. Despite a household income reaching six figures, she uses cash for every purchase. “What we have is what we have,” Ms. Merhaut said. “We have to rely on the money that weâ€™re bringing in.”
The shift under way feels to some analysts like a cultural inflection point, one with huge implications for an economy driven overwhelmingly by consumer spending.
While some experts question whether most Americans, particularly baby boomers, will ever give up their buy-now/pay-later way of life, the unraveling of the real estate market appears to have left millions of families with little choice, yanking fresh credit from their grasp.
“The long collapse in the United States savings rate is over,” said Ethan S. Harris, chief United States economist for Lehman Brothers. “People are going to start saving the old-fashioned way, rather than letting the stock market and rising home values do it for them.”
You can check out the rest of the story here.
I’ll keep an eye out for further evidence of a sea-change in consumer borrowing behavior and signs of increased savings. Send me any evidence you have that consumers are embracing the New Frugality–or perhaps I should call it the forced embrace of the New Frugality.
We’re here to help you navigate this changed world and economy.
Our mission at Marketplace is to raise the economic intelligence of the country. It’s a tough task, but it’s never been more important.
In the past year, we’ve seen record unemployment, stimulus bills, and reddit users influencing the stock market. Marketplace helps you understand it all, will fact-based, approachable, and unbiased reporting.
Generous support from listeners and readers is what powers our nonprofit news—and your donation today will help provide this essential service. For just $5/month, you can sustain independent journalism that keeps you and thousands of others informed.